MOPEN METAL
ALBUM LIBRARYFREE-TO-READ ARCHIVE
← Back to the archive
RSS
Magyar English Deutsch
Newsletter updatesSubscribe to the newsletter

CHAPTERS · 10

01The Names in the Margin of the Booklet
    02Court, City, Forest
    • The regular streets, marketplace and distinctive…
    • In 1618, the establishment comprised five musicians…
    • The earliest reasonably secure written reference in the…
    03Workshops and Stations
    • With industrialisation, even the districts growing…
    • Public music in the city could attract audiences in more…
    • More buildings survived the war in Ludwigsburg. The…
    04Before the Club Filled Up
    • Stuttgart punk’s early years, from 1977 to 1983, could…
    • On 30 November 1983, Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik opened in…
    • Mathias Röderer, or Matze as he was called in…
    05October at the Rockfabrik
    • Blue Blood remained available by mail order. Speaking to…
    • At the same time, entirely different worlds of guitar and…
    • The new holiday replaced an older date. The protests of…
    06A Year Between Two Albums
    • Atrocity’s concert list records sixteen shows with Sodom…
    • He recalled two different audience figures for concerts…
    • For Morgoth’s album Cursed, Sebastian Swart cited the…
    07Three Locations for the Recording
    • After reunification, the eastern states faced even more…
    • During the war years, Baden-Württemberg became an…
    • While shops were taking shape around the station…
    08The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them
    • When Godless Years begins, images of mortality give way…
    • During the minute and a half of Introduction, the album’s…
    • Gianna Possehl brought dark, dried roses to the cover…
    09Two Calendars
    • The changes in the September weather are particularly…
    • Atrocity undertook the tour after completing their second…
    • On forums and music databases in the 2000s, listeners…
    10Memories That Became Part of the Album
    • By the time of Atlantis in 2004, Krull looked back on the…
    Beginning of bookSources and references

    ATROCITY – Todessehnsucht

    Magyar English Deutsch

    Uses installed browser voices for narration.

    ATROCITY · 1992 · The record and its historic surroundings

    Todessehnsucht

    Released: 1992 · Roadrunner Records, original edition
    MagyarEnglishDeutsch
    Start reading ↓

    A complete ten-chapter album history with 134 detailed source notes.

    Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (1992), original cover

    Original cover-issue credits

    Original cover artwork and photography: Gianna Possehl. Period photography: Christian Brunch. These are historical credits and do not assert image-use permission.

    Album details

    Tracklist · original 1992 CD (11 tracks)

    1. 01. Todessehnsucht3:48
    2. 02. Godless Years5:37
    3. 03. Unspoken Names5:25
    4. 04. Defiance4:56
    5. 05. Triumph at Dawn4:00
    6. 06. Introduction1:32
    7. 07. Sky Turned Red6:22
    8. 08. Necropolis4:09
    9. 09. A Prison Called Earth6:03
    10. 10. Todessehnsucht (Reprise)2:03
    11. 11. Archangel3:27

    47:22 · original 1992 CD (documented track times)

    Band members and contributors

    • Alexander Krull — vocals, keyboards, sequencer
    • Mathias Röderer — guitars
    • Richard Scharf — guitars
    • Oliver Klasen — bass
    • Michael Schwarz — drums
    • Robert Russ — countertenor
    • Stefan Weible — tenor
    • Johannes Puschel — baritone
    • Florian Löthe — bass (voice)

    Recording and release

    • Mainstreet Studio · Fautspach — recording
    • Daylight Studios · Stuttgart — mixing
    • Bauer Studios · Ludwigsburg — mastering
    • Roadrunner Records · 1992 · RR 9128.2
    • Massacre Records · 2020 · MAS LP1138 (vinyl reissue)

    Verified album services

    SpotifyApple Music

    Digital availability

    ◈ATROCITY · TodessehnsuchtLabel catalogue information, not proof of availability

    Physical releases / product pages

    ▣Fnac · 2020 LPProduct page · check stock with the seller▣MediaMarkt · 2020 LPNot available to order on the checked page▣Massacre Records · 2020Label catalogue information, not proof of availability

    Official band channels and profiles

    Official websiteInstagramMetal Archives
    Share this article
    FacebookXWhatsAppTelegramRedditEmail
    Reading:
    01 / 10

    The Names in the Margin of the Booklet

    Three place names appear close together in the booklet accompanying the first edition of Todessehnsucht. Fautspach is listed for recording, Stuttgart for mixing, and Ludwigsburg for mastering. Anyone who had read the small print on Atrocity’s previous full-length album might already have noticed the order of those names. Back then, they had travelled all the way to Florida in pursuit of a sound they knew from their favourite records. This time, they took the same work to three locations in Germany. The distance was shorter; the time devoted to the record was longer. On the finished recordings, alongside the two guitars and the rhythm section, there were Alex Krull’s keyboards, a sequencer, and four guest vocalists.1

    According to the printed credits, recording began in the wooded countryside around Fautspach. Written evidence of an organ in Stuttgart survives from centuries earlier, while court music had already been heard in Ludwigsburg as the town itself was taking shape. In the end, places with very different histories were connected by the stages of work on a single album. Before Atrocity could carry their tapes into the studio in 1992, a town had grown up around a palace, new kinds of work had emerged in the industrial region, and metal musicians had learned to organise their own concerts.2

    Next chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    02 / 10

    Court, City, Forest

    The oldest layer of the story leads to the Neckar. Near present-day Bad Cannstatt, the Romans maintained a fort from around AD 90. The traditional account of Stuttgart’s name traces it to the establishment of a stud farm around 950; the written name of the settlement can be followed back to the twelfth century and its status as a town to the thirteenth. From the fourteenth century onwards, the counts of Württemberg increasingly made it their residence and burial place. Around the Stiftskirche, the routines of collective worship and church music were established long before the arrival of industry.3

    On 7 May 1704, Eberhard Ludwig began building a palace near Erlachhof. Soon, however, the summer residence needed room not only for court buildings but also for streets and houses. An appeal issued on 17 August 1709 therefore offered prospective settlers plots, building materials and relief from public levies: alongside the palace, the new community needed producers and merchants. Growth accelerated when the court moved in during 1715, and on 3 September 1718 a ducal decree raised Ludwigsburg to the status of a town and residential seat.4

    The regular streets, marketplace and distinctive townhouses gradually gave Ludwigsburg an urban form. For a long time, however, livelihoods depended on whether the court was present or absent. According to Otto Schifferer’s figures, the population stood at six hundred in 1718; within a few decades it had risen to 5,668. When the court returned to Stuttgart in 1733, around 2,443 people remained. Carl Eugen kept his court in Ludwigsburg again between 1764 and 1775, and by 1774 the population had reached 11,607. The next departure brought another sharp decline. These changes involved more than houses: the court household provided work, a porcelain workshop could operate, musicians and a stage needed premises, and audiences followed the performances.5

    Württemberg became a duchy in 1495. With the Reformation, both the court and ecclesiastical life had to be reorganised. The Thirty Years’ War, from 1618 to 1648, shattered that order. According to an estimate in the town’s history, only about 4,500 of Stuttgart’s roughly ten thousand inhabitants remained after the military campaigns and epidemics. Villages in the wooded countryside experienced the effects of the same war in communities of an entirely different scale.6

    The canons from Beutelsbach came to Stuttgart around 1321. An organ at the Stiftskirche is mentioned in written records as early as 1381, and musicians were performing organised duties in the court chapel by 1495. The names of Sebastian Virdung and Heinrich Finck have survived from early court music, as has that of the later Leonhard Lechner. Lechner became associated with Stuttgart around 1585–86 and was working as the chapel’s musical director by 1594. For centuries, the organ, singers and trained music master had repeatedly to bring the music intended for worship into harmony.7

    In 1618, the establishment comprised five musicians alongside a music master. During the Thirty Years’ War, especially around 1634, the organisation that supported the ensemble fell apart. In the 1650s, the revival of music came to be associated with Philipp Friedrich Böddecker. When Johann Pachelbel served as an organist in Stuttgart between 1690 and 1692, there was once again a place for the work that the war had interrupted. In the following century, part of that work continued in another town.8

    In 1728, the orchestra was moved to Ludwigsburg. The relocation of the court was thus reflected in the musicians’ place of work as well. At the residence, festivities and evenings at the theatre expressed the court’s prestige, while the town also bore the costs that came with its institutions. Musical theatre assumed a particularly prominent place under Carl Eugen. Niccolò Jommelli was associated with it from 1754 as court composer and conductor, and in 1761 the Académie des Arts was founded in Ludwigsburg. The sound of Italian opera became part of Württemberg court life.9

    Preparations were under way in Stuttgart for Carl Eugen’s thirty-fifth birthday on 11 February 1763. For the occasion, Jommelli produced a new version of Pietro Metastasio’s story of Dido, which he had previously set to music in Rome in 1748 and Vienna in 1749. Towards the end of the ducal evening, a storm and Neptune appeared on stage. Jean-Georges Noverre’s choreography, set to music by Florian Deller, carried the performance onwards to the triumph of the sea god. Music and staging adapted the tragic story’s conclusion to the purpose of a birthday celebration.10

    The earliest reasonably secure written reference in the local history preserving Sechselberg’s past is a charter dated 1027, from the reign of Conrad II; the story of Saxon settlers arriving between 794 and 804 is less certain. The names of neighbouring places appear later in the records: Lutzenberg in 1407, Kallenberg in 1408 and Schöllhütte in 1459. Althütte remained part of Unterweissach until 1819. Across the wooded hills and settlements of the present-day municipality, which covers 1,816 hectares, the difference in elevation exceeds two hundred metres. Alongside the land itself, timber and glass could provide a livelihood for those who settled here.11

    In Andreas Kieser’s depiction from 1686, the village appears under the name Fautsbach. Roads and small plots of land are visible among the red roofs, with forest beyond. A few decades earlier, war and disease had struck entire settlements within this rural order. Schöllhütte was depopulated for a time. Livelihoods gradually returned through smallholdings, glassworks and domestic crafts. After glassmaking ceased, crucibles and the remains of glassworks were left behind. Itinerant sellers carried wooden rakes further afield; on the basis of a church document from 1855, the local account mentions some forty thousand tools produced. Around Sechselberg, larger estates and agricultural labour divided the work differently.12

    Anna Haag, the teacher’s daughter, was born on 10 July 1888 in the Althütte schoolhouse built in 1873. She later became a writer and an advocate of women’s rights and peace. The local museum connects her work in Württemberg-Baden with conscientious objection to military service and, indirectly, with the relevant provision of the 1949 Basic Law. The museum opened in the same building on 30 April 1988, exhibiting objects from local trades and the former life of the community.13

    Piped water came from the forest too. From 1929, the Lambach pump in Fautspach used water from the Ochsenhau spring at a rate of 0.77 litres per second; from 1937, the equipment beside the Nonnenmühle supplied Althütte at 63 litres per minute. The water-powered machines remained in use until 1960. By then, new families had moved onto plots designated from the 1950s onwards. On 27 October 1970, Althütte was officially declared a holiday resort. Soon the inhabitants would also have to vote on where the municipality’s boundaries should lie.14

    Of the votes cast in Sechselberg on 23 May 1971, more than 58 per cent favoured a merger with Althütte. Four days later, on 27 May, the agreement was signed in Waldenweiler, and on 1 July the joint municipal authority came into being. Fautspach still had a separate choice to make about its future: on 7 November it opted for Murrhardt, but on 4 June 1972, by forty-three votes to forty-one, it chose Althütte after all. The administrative lawsuit was subsequently withdrawn. In the recollections of Gotthold Muff and Friedrich Heinle, two former councillors, arguments both for and against the reform remained. The everyday importance of the school, the church, the sewerage system and the route to work was unchanged by the name on the town hall. Fautspach retained its own name after the merger; later, that name would appear in an Atrocity album booklet too.15

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    03 / 10

    Workshops and Stations

    By the time the court finally departed in 1816, the town had to sustain several kinds of livelihood side by side. People tried their hand at leather, silk, metal, glass and woollen cloth. The cloth works attached to a workhouse and orphanage in 1736–37 proved more enduring than many other workshops. The ducal porcelain manufactory, founded in 1758, remained in operation until 1824. Soldiers, meanwhile, shaped the trade of the shops: 1736 is given for the construction of the first barracks, while the museum dates the beginning of the garrison-town era to 1737. That latter story continued all the way to 1994. Duties were collected at the gates, and people entering and leaving were monitored, partly to prevent soldiers from deserting. The name “Swabian Potsdam” survived from this long period in the town’s history.16

    For craftsmen in Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg, the lack of raw materials and water power was not the only limit on the size of their workshops; transport mattered too. Preparations for a railway began in 1836, and in 1844 Karl Etzel laid out the route towards Stuttgart and Zuffenhausen. A year later, the Cannstatt–Untertürkheim–Esslingen section was built. A trial train from Stuttgart reached Ludwigsburg on 30 September 1846; the ceremonial opening followed on 15 October. A two-hour journey by stagecoach became one of roughly half an hour. For the carrier, that time disappeared from a familiar line of work; for the factories, it brought the other town that much closer.17

    With industrialisation, even the districts growing towards the railway did not expand at the same pace. Thomas Schwarz’s figures for 1851–1900 show growth of 248 per cent in Stuttgart’s central area, 428 per cent in Gaisburg and 298 per cent in Bad Cannstatt. In Ludwigsburg, engineering, metalworking, textile and food-processing businesses appeared alongside the Walcker organ-building workshop, established in 1820, and the Nast printing house of 1824. The history of Franck’s coffee-substitute factory is traced to 1868. Yet the old character of the garrison town survived alongside civilian employment: in 1910 Schifferer counted 5,113 soldiers in addition to 22,774 civilian inhabitants.18

    After the world war, jobs vanished as the garrison was reduced. The town converted empty military buildings to civilian use and tried to attract new factories with industrial sites and railway sidings. There were still 80 industrial enterprises on record in 1919, rising to 114 by 1927; the Wüstenrot building society also moved here in 1928. The economic crisis, however, interrupted the recovery. According to Schifferer, the number of enterprises fell to 111 in 1930, 109 in 1933 and 98 in 1937. Rearmament then assigned an altogether different kind of work to the same town.19

    The scale of Stuttgart, meanwhile, was changing rapidly. From around 91,000 inhabitants in 1871, its population reached 286,000 in 1910. Beyond the factories, theatre, the press, education and municipal utilities grew as well. The incorporation of Cannstatt, the state theatres opened in 1912, the Weissenhof Estate, the Tagblatt Tower and the Schocken department store gave visible form to this larger city.20

    Public music in the city could attract audiences in more than one setting. The Liederkranz choral society was founded in 1824, a work by Wagner was staged in 1859, the Liederhalle opened in 1864, and Brahms’s Requiem was performed in 1871. In February 1857, twenty-two musicians, teachers and lovers of the arts published an appeal for a music school. The school opened on 15 April under the direction of Sigmund Lebert, a native of Ludwigsburg. According to the official history, three-quarters of its pupils studied as amateurs. For someone drawn to music, learning to play for personal pleasure became a genuine path in its own right.21

    From 1896, the Stuttgart school operated under the name Royal Conservatory. In 1921, the previously unified organisation of professional and amateur training was divided. Thereafter, a student preparing for a performing career and one making music at home attended different institutions.22

    After 1933, the dictatorship reshaped factories and administration to serve its own purposes. Stuttgart’s Jewish residents were driven from public and economic life. The municipal historical overview reports roughly 2,500 Jewish people deported from Stuttgart and Württemberg, and mentions around 700 forced labourers within a specified local context. Sinti and Roma communities were persecuted too. During the later years of the war, transport routes, industrial areas and residential neighbourhoods were repeatedly bombed. Following the most devastating attacks in 1944, the city’s summary puts the death toll at approximately 4,500. Reconstruction required homes, utilities, schools and workplaces to be restored at the same time.23

    More buildings survived the war in Ludwigsburg. The garrison and industry still belonged to the same town, which came under French and then American control in the spring of 1945. Life in the garrison changed after 1945. Some of the remaining military properties passed to a new army, and later still to new civilian users.24

    At the same time, more and more people needed homes. Returning soldiers, refugees, expellees and new industrial workers reached the limited housing stock by different routes. A demographic historical account estimates approximately 320,000 war deaths across the entire territory of what later became Baden-Württemberg, more than forty thousand of them civilians. In 1952, Baden, Württemberg-Baden and Württemberg-Hohenzollern merged to form the new state, with Stuttgart as its capital.25

    Pattonville, with homes and a school, was built for Americans on the southeastern outskirts of Ludwigsburg in 1954. Grünbühl and other residential districts developed around different industrial and housing needs. During the 1950s and 1960s, larger numbers of workers arrived first from Italy, then from Yugoslavia, Spain, Portugal and Turkey. Their family and workplace ties found a place among the towns. In this setting, the railway connection established in 1846 took on a new suburban role. The first S-Bahn service began in 1978, and later the S4 and S5 lines further reshaped the routes people could take to work each day.26

    The opera singer and teacher Karl Adler was removed from the leadership of the Neues Konservatorium in 1933 because of his Jewish background. The institution was closed in 1936, and its property passed into the orbit of Kraft durch Freude. The war also severely damaged the Stiftskirche and its organ. In the 1950s, instruments and functioning institutions once again had to be provided for an urban musical culture that had lost both teachers and buildings.27

    Regular concerts began at Ludwigsburg Palace in 1932. In 1947, a series of Mozart Days and thirty-four concerts under the title Schlosskonzerte gave the programme fresh momentum. Audiences now came from the city into the very rooms where the court had once provided the occasion for performances. A youth music school opened in Stuttgart in 1951, followed by adult music education in 1953. The two were merged in 1968 and passed into municipal administration in 1976. Audiences and musical education thus continued to grow within a different organisational framework.28

    Hans-Peter Haag dates one of his first concerts, with the band Erna Schmidt, to October 1971. Admission was three marks, and according to his recollection the band was paid four hundred marks. Six years later, his concert promotion activities were operating under the name Stuttgart Music Circus. According to his recollections, AC/DC played the Gustav-Siegle-Haus on 28 September 1977. Tickets cost ten marks, and roughly seven hundred people attended. The clubs that followed had to solve the same problem preserved in Haag’s memory of a single evening’s prices: there had to be a venue and a band, and somebody willing to pay for both.29

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    04 / 10

    Before the Club Filled Up

    After the oil crises, unemployment appeared in figures that made it difficult to discern the earlier pace of economic growth. For 1974, the year Helmut Schmidt succeeded Brandt as chancellor, Axel Schildt gives a rate of 2.6 per cent. The following year it was 4.7 per cent; by 1982 it was 7.5. Meanwhile, roads, energy projects and airports had to be built amid controversy. Schildt estimates that some 1.8 million people were involved in such citizens’ initiatives by 1978. The Greens received only 1.5 per cent of the vote in 1980, but entered parliament with 5.6 per cent in 1983.30

    The German Autumn of 1977 brought Stuttgart-Stammheim into the national headlines as well. The RAF’s violence, the imprisonment of its members and police action sparked debate about domestic security. In NATO’s 1979 Double-Track Decision, arms-control negotiations were placed alongside the possibility of deploying intermediate-range missiles. Some regarded the two steps as interdependent; others feared that the danger would grow. A historical overview estimates that around four hundred thousand people attended the peace demonstration in Bonn on 10 June 1982. That same year the coalition between the SPD and FDP collapsed. Helmut Kohl took over the government with CDU/CSU–FDP support.31

    Stuttgart punk’s early years, from 1977 to 1983, could not be contained within the walls of a single club. Simon Steiner later collected the recollections of approximately 120 people; from their accounts he catalogued around two hundred bands, 150 tapes, fifty records and as many fanzines. The music found its own communities in Winnenden, Tübingen, Ludwigsburg, Böblingen and Pforzheim as well. Dan Peter linked the beginnings of The Beauties in 1977 both to the punk he had encountered in England and to a school in Stuttgart. Around the Mausefalle, Tangente and Exil, news of gigs, tapes and personal connections often travelled through the same people.32

    Normahl’s first performance at the Karls-Gymnasium is dated to 1978. Meanwhile, The Zeros became Chaos Z around 1980; alongside concerts by the Cure and Abwärts, Andreas Löhr also remembered an evening in 1980 in Sindelfingen featuring Norma(h)l and Fehlprodukt. Chaos Z played the Mausefalle on 19 January 1983 and later sought a darker sound under the name Fliehende Stürme. Club nights thus gave room not to one single strand of punk but to musical paths developing side by side. As names and sounds changed, so did the clubs’ programmes, while the city’s venues carried on.33

    For Armin Hofmann, memories of the clubs and youth centres around Nagold and Tübingen were intertwined with the stories of Skeezicks and X-Mist. Work on their own demos and fanzines also set in motion the small-scale distribution network that grew out of ExtremMist: letters, tapes and gig contacts travelled onwards. Toxoplasma and D.O.A. were among the names associated with such shared occasions. The routes Hofmann recalled reached stops in northern Italy and as far as Amsterdam. An envelope and tape first put together for a local audience could meanwhile find new listeners far beyond the town.34

    On 30 November 1983, Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik opened in the hall of a former refrigerator factory. Through its contacts with magazines, agencies and record labels, local audiences could encounter touring bands from abroad there too. On 2 March 1984, Thomas Müller and Udo Heller opened the Longhorn in Stuttgart-Wangen. It started as a country-and-western saloon, with members of the American military community stationed nearby among its customers. A few years later people came to the same place for altogether different music. The two venues emerged from different audiences; both would have a night of their own in Atrocity’s story.35

    In Ludwigsburg in 1985, a new loud band could already rehearse close to several different audiences. Someone who studied church music, someone whose first concert had taken place in a youth centre and someone who frequented the Rockfabrik each found their kind of music in a different place. Stuttgart also had the Longhorn, with its own original clientele. Into this network of local clubs came the new group, which two years later would have to decide what its own sound should be.36

    The first line-up began in thrash and used the name Instigator. One contemporary interview dates the beginnings to 1985, while other sources also use the form Instigators. Alex Krull’s life was tied to Ludwigsburg. According to Krull, the original members wanted different things from their music. He himself was drawn towards an increasingly extreme direction. When he later spoke of the change, he mentioned the technical playing of Watchtower and Coroner as naturally as the heaviness of Napalm Death and Morbid Angel. Krull said that they chose the name Atrocity without knowing of the British punk band of the same name. After changes in personnel around 1988, the whole band could begin testing how these ideas might coexist within a single song.37

    Mathias Röderer, or Matze as he was called in conversations, began his explanation of the change by saying that he and Alex had wanted faster, more brutal music, and needed to find others who shared that ambition. He dated Oli Klasen’s arrival to February 1989. He recalled Migge Schwarz as a drummer looking for a sound of his own. For the seven-inch tracks, Röderer still stressed his own role as a writer, but when discussing the later songs he gave everyone a place in the story. In Blasphemous, the five names appeared together: Alex, Matze, Richard Scharf, Oli and Migge. The magazine listed Klasen’s instrument differently in one place from the way it would appear on the 1992 CD. On the finished album he played bass.38

    On 26 April 1986, a reactor at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant exploded. Winds carried radioactive material towards several countries. Increased radiation was measured at Forsmark in Sweden, and those readings were among the first public signs of the disaster in the West. Before long, milk, leafy vegetables and drinking water became matters of concern. Parents feared their children’s exposure, while recommendations differed between states and countries. Melanie Arndt also recorded the protests in Stuttgart that May. A separate federal environment ministry was established in early June. After the disaster, even questions of everyday life required answers from authorities whose thresholds for radiation measurements and approaches to food inspection were far from uniform.39

    On 1 July 1987, the Single European Act, signed the previous year, entered into force. It provided a framework for the common market of the European Communities and for strengthening the parliamentary role. That autumn, a more tangible rearrangement took place in Ludwigsburg: on 8 October the central bus station and the Franck pedestrian bridge were inaugurated. The old station building was demolished later the same month. A new entrance opened on the site five years later. Meanwhile, a very different building in the forest gained a new purpose: from 1988 the former school in Althütte preserved objects of village working life as a museum.40

    While the western part of the country debated economic and social questions, people involved in peace and environmental movements had already gained a presence within institutions. In the East, the operation of the government and the state-run economy became increasingly urgent questions. In the autumn of 1989, relations between the two sides changed far more rapidly than anyone might have expected even a few months earlier.41

    In 1986, Metallica and Slayer records appeared in the pages of the same music press that taught listeners to argue about speed, vocals and drum sounds. Discussing Kreator’s Pleasure to Kill, a later retrospective also singled out Harris Johns’s recording work and the importance of the drums. Thrash and the emerging death metal shared many recognisable devices. A year later, Switzerland’s Celtic Frost sought a new form on Into the Pandemonium through female and operatic voices, wind instruments and strings. Tom Gabriel Warrior later connected the band’s disputes with the Noise label to the very artistic freedom they needed for their unusual arrangements.42

    Holger Stratmann and Uwe Lerch launched Dortmund’s Rock Hard as a fanzine in 1983. By 1987 it was distributed nationwide. Metal Hammer, launched in 1984, offered a flexi-disc and a Soundcheck section from 1985 onwards. Both magazines could bring records made in very different clubs and countries closer to one another. Meanwhile, after its country beginnings, the Longhorn was ready for a different sort of major performance. Nina Hagen played there on 14 December 1987; the venue regards it as its first major concert.43

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    05 / 10

    October at the Rockfabrik

    In 1989, the Blue Blood seven-inch was something the band could take with them whenever they wanted to show someone how far they had come in rehearsal. Krull heard in it their first deliberate meeting of technique and raw force. While preparing for the next record, he would already have taken several things further, but they continued playing the songs for a time. Alongside the record, the Rockfabrik offered another meeting place. A musician might find themselves in the same room as a fanzine editor, a band looking for a gig or a listener collecting tapes. Krull also became involved in the regional publication Rockfabrik Live. He later recalled a circulation of thirty thousand copies.44

    Krull organised his first underground festival there in October 1989. For the following summer he already wanted to invite Carcass. Arranging the proposed concert in Ludwigsburg also meant making sure the other band had a route into which that evening would fit. What began as a single date would grow into organisational work spanning several countries.45

    Blue Blood remained available by mail order. Speaking to Depth of Pain, Krull was already talking about more than four thousand copies, and about how they would play the songs differently with the knowledge they had by then. At the beginning of a later documentary, the early tapes are accompanied by memories of looking for a rehearsal space: they practised in a cellar, then in a cold farm building or garage. The demos were offered through lists prepared by hand or on a machine, and passed on in letters between Europe and America. The rehearsal room and the post were at least as much a part of the work as the microphone.46

    Inside Morrisound in Tampa, Scott Burns worked on the details of a fast, dense death-metal sound. Morbid Angel’s Altars of Madness, Obituary’s Slowly We Rot and Terrorizer’s World Downfall were recorded at the same studio. Looking back on that period, Burns emphasised microphone placement, drum treatment, gating and track allocation: the snare had to remain audible even in the fastest passages, while the lower frequencies could not be allowed to swallow the bass entirely. In Stockholm, a different sound began to emerge with Tomas Skogsberg’s Nihilist recordings in 1988. At Sunlight, the HM-2 distortion pedal, low tuning and compressed guitar tone led towards Entombed’s Left Hand Path in 1990. Skogsberg spoke of starting with eight tracks and later working with sixteen. The two studios made different decisions about how much of each instrument should remain separately audible in a mass of competing sounds.47

    In Dortmund, Robert Kampf opened a new path for bands by founding Century Media in 1988. According to Marc Grewe’s recollections of Morgoth, they were still calling their extremely fast music “Ultra Thrash” in 1987; the four-track work on Pits of Utumno was later followed by a twenty-four-track demo recording. In southern Germany, Markus Staiger built Nuclear Blast from 1987 onwards out of punk and hardcore releases. In a contemporary interview, Röderer praised him because Atrocity could reach him easily. Beyond studio technology, the fate of a rehearsal-room idea increasingly depended on whom one could approach in the record business.48

    At the same time, entirely different worlds of guitar and rhythm could be heard in Stuttgart. The chronology records a concert by Einstürzende Neubauten with The Young Gods on 4 July 1988. Thus experimental and industrial music found room at the Longhorn during the very period in which thrash was turning into death metal in the surrounding area.49

    On 12 June 1989, Kohl and Mikhail Gorbachev held talks in Bad Godesberg. A diplomatic report on East German opposition groups survives from September, and an internal ruling-party economic analysis from 30 October. On 9 November the crossing points in the Berlin Wall were opened. In the following weeks, the government, the opposition and the ruling party sought in different places to shape what would follow. Hans Modrow delivered a government statement on 17 November, and on 3 December the SED Central Committee passed a resolution. The round-table talks changed the decision-making process simply by granting opposition groups a seat at the table.50

    By February 1990, preparations for an election were under way. On 6 April, Sabine Bergmann-Pohl became president of the Volkskammer, and on 12 April Lothar de Maizière formed a government. Different forums decided the fate of finances, accession, border installations and state-security files. The decision to accede was taken on 23 August, and the Unification Treaty was signed on 31 August. Unity took effect on 3 October.51

    The new holiday replaced an older date. The protests of 17 June 1953 grew from discontent over work quotas and supplies into a nationwide political uprising. The Bundesarchiv mentions around seven hundred affected towns and roughly ten thousand people detained. As early as 4 August 1953, West Germany made 17 June a day of German unity by law. Now the calendar marked a different date. For someone seeking a job or their family, where they could live and work still mattered. Baden-Württemberg became a destination for many during these years.52

    The tour planned around a Carcass concert did not yet exist when Krull discussed the invitation with the band. According to his recollections, he first organised five shows in three countries, and the run eventually spread to nine countries. He mentioned an average audience of five hundred, and two thousand at one concert in Czechoslovakia. He recalled the Paris show with particular pleasure. These figures come from the memories of a singer who also worked as an organiser; behind them lay the same everyday task as on the first evening in Ludwigsburg: venues, performers and transport had to be made to fit together.53

    The studio sessions for Hallucinations also had to be entered into the tour calendar. Harris Johns’s schedule clashed with the Carcass trip, while Fleming Rasmussen would have cost too much. For a while, the plan was to involve Scott Burns in mixing. In the end, the sound of Death’s Leprosy and Sepultura’s Beneath the Remains convinced Krull and his bandmates to entrust the entire recording to Morrisound. Obituary provided a drum kit in Tampa. Krull recalled meeting musicians from Incubus, Obituary, Deicide and Morbid Angel there, with only brief contact with Glen Benton. In a later interview, he estimated the Florida studio time at five to seven days. According to his account, they had to play in Hamburg on the very day they returned home.54

    The first album follows the tragic story of a girl from beginning to end. Poverty and childhood trauma were as much a part of Krull’s conception as addiction and death. The singer began from his own anti-drug position, but also wanted the story to show the circumstances in which the girl lived. Meanwhile, he looked elsewhere for the album’s visual identity. They considered both Salvador Dalí and H. R. Giger; in the end Krull contacted Giger by telephone and then sent him the tape. Hallucinations thus acquired a distinct story and an image chosen to accompany it.55

    Following its release, Krull estimated sales during the first six weeks at around sixteen thousand copies. During the shows with Sodom, he found that audiences sometimes struggled to follow the unusual structures. He still wanted music in which force and complexity could be heard together. By then the question was whether Florida would once again be the best place to achieve that sound on the next record.56

    When the interviewer from Underground Empire placed Watchtower and Morbid Angel alongside Atrocity in the same sentence, Krull found the comparison useful. Röderer, too, heard things that interested him in the playing of Watchtower and Sieges Even. Yet the finished music had to retain its own force. In the studio, the same distinction had to be drawn between a familiar sound and one of their own. For Hallucinations, Morrisound had been the place to do it; for the following album, the band took the tapes elsewhere.57

    German bands followed several diverging routes between the studio and distribution. Scott Burns was associated with the mixing of Morgoth’s The Eternal Fall EP; looking back on tours with Autopsy and Pestilence, Marc Grewe also recalled how far Century Media’s distribution reached in those days and how the concert programmes differed from place to place. Roadrunner already handled a much larger catalogue. Cees Wessels’s Dutch company had been operating since 1980: it released a King Diamond record in 1987, and Sepultura’s Arise also appeared in its catalogue in 1991. Thus, before Atrocity’s next album, the scale of the label network and the question of control over the recordings came to the fore together.58

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    06 / 10

    A Year Between Two Albums

    On 2 August 1990, Iraq invaded Kuwait. In Resolution 660, the Security Council demanded withdrawal. After sanctions and negotiations, an international coalition launched a war in the Persian Gulf in early 1991. The Bundesarchiv distinguishes the preceding Desert Shield deployment from the military operation that followed. German Alpha Jet aircraft were assigned a defensive role in Turkey under NATO’s Ace Guard operation. The archive mentions eighteen aircraft. In Germany, demonstrators and constitutional debates sought answers to the question of what role the country should play. The same war also became a question in an Atrocity interview.59

    Earlier layers of the South Slav state’s history led back to the rearrangements between 1912 and 1921, its partition in 1941 and the reorganisation that followed the war. In June 1991, Slovenia’s bid for independence led to armed conflict, followed by fighting in Croatia. Through networks of Yugoslav migrant workers established over previous decades, many people in Germany had relatives or acquaintances still living in a region drifting towards war. By 1992, families from Bosnia and Herzegovina were also heading towards those connections.60

    Atrocity’s concert list records sixteen shows with Sodom between 19 January and 6 February 1991. After Osnabrück and Bremen came Hamburg, Berlin, Nuremberg and Frankfurt; Ludwigshafen, Winterthur, Vienna, Munich and Stuttgart were also on the route. At the Longhorn, the band was playing in its own region, at a stop on a tour that would take it far from home for an extended period. Performances in eastern Germany and Poland followed in the spring, Bamberg in the summer, and Dutch and Belgian dates with Sinister in September. Krull later recalled that members of Sinister also listened to an advance recording of the new Atrocity material. He and Röderer subsequently worked with them on the production of Cross the Styx.61

    Speaking to Spikehead, Krull still talked enthusiastically about Tampa and Scott Burns. He discussed a tour with Disharmonic Orchestra or Nocturnus, and the possibility of a tour overseas. Such plans were constrained by the time limits of civilian service. In the same fanzine, he was asked about the fall of the Wall and the dangers of the war in Iraq. The band’s future, the obligations governing its members’ lives and the changing country around them were still parts of the same conversation.62

    Röderer was studying, while Krull was carrying out civilian service. When he was later asked about their working routine, the singer described three rehearsals a week. The guitarists brought in many ideas, but most decisions still had to be worked out among five differing opinions. Krull also counted as part of the work the hours they allowed themselves away from music. Meanwhile, he regarded the studio options as more limited: many records opted for an established sound resembling that of other releases. On the next Atrocity recording, he wanted to hear the band’s own solutions.63

    He recalled two different audience figures for concerts in Poland: in Depth of Pain he spoke of about six thousand at a Metal Mania appearance, while in Aberration he mentioned more than eight thousand at an evening in Poland. The interviews leave it uncertain whether these were the same event. Master, Pungent Stench, Morbid Angel and Napalm Death also appear in these contemporary concert memories. Meanwhile, the rhythm of touring could be interrupted for long periods by service obligations. According to Krull, civilian service could involve working in hospitals, with older people or with people with disabilities. They expected that, after several further months of service, they could request leave for tours.64

    Steve Flynn was already discussing Atheist’s Unquestionable Presence in 1991. He estimated two to three weeks for the guitar parts, while the shifts and accents associated with the drumming continued to take shape. Alongside Scott Burns’s work at Morrisound, he considered it important that the bass should be heard distinctly. That allowed the bass to follow its own melody even within a rhythmic density that, Flynn said, listeners needed time to absorb. Death’s Human appeared in the same year, becoming another defining recording for the more technical and progressive direction of the genre.65

    Formed in 1988, Paradise Lost followed 1990’s Lost Paradise by recording Gothic at Academy Studios in late 1990 and early 1991. Alongside the heavy riffs, slowing down, vocals and a dark atmosphere took on quite different roles. An editorial account of Greg Mackintosh’s later memories places the band’s performance at Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik on 14 April 1991. After the 1990 demo Towards the Sinister, My Dying Bride released the God Is Alone single in 1991 and then As the Flower Withers in 1992. Around death metal, instrumental density, slowness and a mournful atmosphere could thus be developed at the same time.66

    For Morgoth’s album Cursed, Sebastian Swart cited the dark gothic rock of Fields of the Nephilim as a musical reference. In the recollections of Marc Grewe and Swart, recording and touring belonged to the same period of work. They associated the mixing of Cursed with Randy Burns, and that of The Eternal Fall with Scott Burns. Two similar names stood alongside two different recording paths. Meanwhile, Atrocity were trying to find their own place in this increasingly divided musical field through a studio at home.67

    In September 1991, four tracks were placed on the early tape with which Atrocity approached Roadrunner. Alongside the title track Unspoken Names were Sky Turned Red, Defiance and A Prison Called Earth. Because these songs had already reached the arrangement stage, the label could hear what sort of music the band wanted the time and independence to create. Falk Gruber and Krull are credited with mixing the advance recording. Krull later valued the early sound of Sky Turned Red in particular: in that version the song sounded somewhat rawer than it did on the album.68

    Speaking to Depth of Pain, Krull described plans to begin recording in January and an album expected in April. Alongside blast beats, he imagined slower passages and ideas drawn from classical music: Watchtower, Nasty Savage and Psychotic Waltz pointed him towards different possibilities. In his interview with Aberration, he returned to these questions from the perspective of the completed album, and to the need to bring five people’s ideas together at rehearsals. His musical horizons accommodated Judas Priest and Iron Maiden as readily as Laibach and Primus; Mozart and Wagner were not excluded by death metal either.69

    During the same period, Krull also mentioned Nocturnus’s The Key, Mike Browning’s early work with Morbid Angel and the music of Type O Negative. He had reservations about the latter band’s lyrics, but admired Nocturnus for its willingness to experiment across genre boundaries. He still regarded himself as an underground musician, even though Carcass, Morbid Angel, Massacre, Master and Immolation had already made full-length albums. Meanwhile, he was planning a side project called Corpus Christi, in which he wanted to sing and play drums, with both string-based and metal pieces. Film music, a two-part release and the involvement of Patrick, known from Disharmonic Orchestra, were all among the plans, not events that had already taken place.70

    The Longhorn’s list places Sonic Youth and Nirvana on the same bill on 29 August 1991. Sepultura, Bad Brains, Bad Religion and Dark Angel appeared there on separate evenings that year. Anyone heading to one of those concerts went to the same place as another audience had a few weeks earlier. Alex Krull’s own listening brought similarly distant labels together. Alongside Death and Entombed he mentioned Psychotic Waltz and Primus, listened to Laibach and dance music, and spoke of Mozart or Wagner too. After pre-production, several different musical ideas could reach an Atrocity record with a single label approval.71

    Blue Blood and Hallucinations had still appeared on Nuclear Blast. Describing the switch, Krull estimated total sales of Hallucinations to date at thirty to forty thousand copies, and considered the accounting inadequate. They also rejected the terms of a new offer, and he spoke of legal action. He said the other label’s offer included worldwide distribution and mentioned seven records in connection with the contract in Copenhagen. Speaking to Aberration, he still assessed the work of the German representative favourably. At that point, he believed the same collaboration might also open a path to concerts in America and possibly Japan. The first tangible result of the partnership was studio work in Germany.72

    Roadrunner built an international catalogue through which several strands of heavy metal reached listeners across national borders. Atrocity were able to enter that circle with their own tape on the condition that the band controlled the sound. The decision would also be legible on the inside of the album: Atrocity as producer, Roadrunner as label.73

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    07 / 10

    Three Locations for the Recording

    Baden-Württemberg passed the ten-million population threshold in 1992. During the year, around 125,000 more people moved into the state than left it. Foreign nationals accounted for approximately seventy per cent of the net migration. The proportion of foreign citizens living in the state rose from 11.5 per cent at the end of 1991 to 12.4 per cent a year later. Some came from the eastern German states after reunification; others arrived to join earlier employment and family connections or to escape war. A later population-history summary puts the four-year net balance of international migration between 1989 and 1992 at almost 470,000. A separate series gives a net gain of nearly 90,000 people from the eastern states between 1990 and 1992.74

    The Bundesbank’s year-end report recorded a slowdown in the West German economy. Real GDP in the third quarter was half a per cent below the preceding quarter on a seasonally adjusted basis. Demand for exports weakened, unit labour costs rose and caution became evident in investment. Between the end of August and the end of November, the seasonally adjusted number of unemployed people in the western states increased by around one hundred thousand to nearly 1.95 million. Consumer prices in November were 3.7 per cent higher than a year earlier; meanwhile, more and more workplaces in Baden-Württemberg introduced short-time working.75

    After reunification, the eastern states faced even more severe labour-market losses. For November the Bundesbank reported approximately 1,086,500 unemployed people, or 13.4 per cent. Production in some industries had already passed its lowest point, but prices, wages and jobs were adjusting at different rates; the statistics counted people on short-time work separately from the unemployed. A national border no longer separated the two parts of Germany, but everyday conditions in their labour markets remained very different.76

    The Treaty on European Union was signed at Maastricht on 7 February 1992. The legal framework for economic and monetary cooperation, Union citizenship, common foreign and security policy and new decision-making procedures entered into force on 1 November 1993. Between signature and entry into force came the exchange-rate crisis of autumn 1992: the lira and pound left the exchange-rate mechanism, while the peseta and escudo were devalued. Even as the treaty set out a shared monetary future, defending the exchange rates of individual currencies remained the immediate task that autumn.77

    Meanwhile, in southeastern Europe, war also broke out in Bosnia and Herzegovina following the Slovenian and Croatian conflicts of 1991. According to the historical reconstruction, by the summer of 1992 fighting following the independence referendum had forced some 2.2 million people to leave their homes within the Bosnian region. Those who arrived in Germany after earlier Yugoslav migrants could find family and work-related connections there. In May 1992 the authorities initially suspended deportations of people arriving from the war zone for three months. The subsequently extended Duldung permitted them to remain temporarily, while leaving their longer-term residence and employment prospects open.78

    During the war years, Baden-Württemberg became an important destination for people seeking refuge. The figures of approximately 47,943 and 60,000 Bosnians living there refer to 1995 and 1996 respectively. Meanwhile, the total number of asylum applications submitted in Germany was roughly 190,000 in 1990, nearly 260,000 in 1991 and approximately 440,000 in 1992. Officials attempted to accommodate people fleeing war within procedures built around proof of individual persecution. Far-right agitation accompanied the legal debate.79

    On 22 August, a racist attack began in Rostock-Lichtenhagen against an asylum seekers’ reception centre and people living in the adjacent building. Those targeted included Roma asylum seekers from Romania and Vietnamese contract workers. Some of the crowd that gathered in the area supported the attackers, while the police response remained inadequate. After the reception centre had been evacuated, on 24 August the building inhabited by Vietnamese residents was set on fire. According to the source, as many as 150 people trapped inside may have sought an escape through a passage leading towards the roof. Political parties reached an agreement on restricting the right to asylum in December; parliament voted on the constitutional amendment in May 1993.80

    Trains had been running between the towns of Württemberg since 1846. Stuttgart’s first S-Bahn service provided a new connection in 1978, and Ludwigsburg’s bus interchange changed in 1987. The old station building had been demolished. Construction of the Bahn-Passage began on the site in 1991, a project costing around 46 million marks and providing some ten thousand square metres of lettable space. The railway history preserves the exact date of its opening: 19 November 1992. Several dates would compete with one another in Atrocity’s calendar that same autumn.81

    While shops were taking shape around the station, Stuttgart’s state administration, industry and cultural institutions remained close to one another. Since the municipal merger, Fautspach had belonged to the Althütte area; the history of its settlements had included forests, village trades and developing water supplies long before any recording studio appeared there. The album passed through three places where even the changes of that same year were visible in different ways.82

    The 1992 concert season in Stuttgart unfolds through widely differing musical evenings in a venue calendar published later. The Longhorn’s retrospective list from 2006 places Overkill on 9 February, Prong on 16 March and Carcass on 29 March as part of Gods of Grind. Paradise Lost appears for 16 April and Obituary for 11 June. In the autumn, concerts in the two neighbouring cities began to overlap. Blind Guardian and Iced Earth are linked to Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik on 20 September.131 The Longhorn calendar lists Testament on 21 September and GWAR on 22 September.132 Sodom followed on 25 October and Helmet on 13 December. Thrash, slower death–doom and alternative music all found space in the region’s halls, while Atrocity’s second album had already begun its own European route through labels and concert venues.83

    The city’s musical life was changing in other buildings too. In 1992, the Stuttgarter Musikschule moved to classrooms and concert halls in the Rotebühlzentrum. Long periods of service were associated with the organ of the Stiftskirche: Martha Schuster had been its organist until the previous year, while Manfred Schreier served as cantor from 1978 to 1994. Night-time venues preserved different kinds of music. The Laboratorium had operated since 1972, Romy S since 1978, Zapata since 1980 and Röhre since 1985; the OZ Keller also appeared on the city’s musical map. By the early 1990s, techno and rave were attracting another distinct audience. Organ music, club concerts and new dance-music evenings thus existed side by side in different, functioning spaces of the same city.84

    Falk Gruber worked with Atrocity on the recording at Mainstreet Studio. The producer credit went to the whole band. Krull recalled to Aberration that roughly four weeks were devoted to the work. Working in Germany, they could sometimes go home to sleep. In Florida, the journey and the days available had required a different pace. For the second album, Krull valued the time gained by being close to home as much as the fact that the band could decide on the sound itself.85

    The tapes went next to Daylight in Stuttgart. Krull worked with Florian Brugger on the mix for approximately two weeks, according to his account. At Bauer Studios in Ludwigsburg, Gerd Puchelt and Krull mastered the album. In the singer’s recollection, the six-week period thus comprised two distinct stages of work. Massacre later also named Wolfgang “Hasche” Hagemann in connection with the drum sound. When the album was remastered at Mastersound in 2020, the engineers were working on the results of those earlier studio sessions.86

    The two guitars were played by Röderer and Scharf. They brought most of the musical ideas, Krull recalled, but the songwriting credits continued to show how often a solution had taken shape differently. Bassist Oliver Klasen and drummer Michael Schwarz also wrote music for Godless Years; elsewhere, one or both of them are absent from the musical songwriting credits. The producer credit remained collective, covering what was necessary for the finished production. Krull handled vocals, keyboards and sequencer.87

    The booklet lists four vocal registers alongside the lead voice: Robert Russ as countertenor, Stefan as tenor, Johannes as baritone and Florian Lothe as bass. The surnames of Stefan and Johannes are difficult to read with certainty. The presence of guest singers was as concrete a part of the album’s sound as the work of the two guitarists. Krull was also occupied with the idea of arrangements on a larger scale. Looking back in 2007, he said they had been unable to raise the money required. In the finished album, the four guest voices stood alongside the other instruments.88

    Anyone turning the page from the five musician portraits encountered a different order of responsibilities. Individual composers appeared beside the songs; the album as a whole carried a collective production credit; the arrangements again named Atrocity. In the meantime, the small print associated with the studios preserved the outside collaborators too. Gruber, Brugger and Puchelt worked on the sound at separate stages, while four guest singers brought different registers to the same music. Through this list of names, even a single part of the finished album’s sound can be traced back to several kinds of work.89

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    08 / 10

    The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them

    A listener to Hallucinations could follow the thread of a single story. For Todessehnsucht, Krull imagined separate, more poetic lyrics. Individual songs address death, power, the landscape after war and the limits of freedom. Even so, the album has a beginning and an ending of its own. Within this arc, the opening musical idea, the transition placed at the centre of the album and the return on track ten are the most clearly marked points.90

    In the opening, Krull set the image of a leaf separating from its branch against Röderer’s music. Some listeners heard the slow beginning of the album as a melody picked out on a distorted guitar; others perceived it along with the impression of strings and timpani. The dark, initially fairly restrained sound later becomes a point of reference: one subsequent interpretation linked the guitar melodies and even the transition into Godless Years to the notes of the opening.91, 92

    When Godless Years begins, images of mortality give way to images of humanity’s own power. Four musicians — Scharf, Klasen, Schwarz and Röderer — are credited with the music. Alternating passages on the drums, some heard as jazzy and others driven by blast beats, give the lyrics a rhythm far removed from the patience of the opening. In one retrospective, this track and Unspoken Names offered the clearest evidence of how the technical rawness of the first album had taken on a more organised form.93, 94

    On the demo, Unspoken Names had to lend its title to all four songs; on the finished album it comes third and has time to dwell on what cannot be spoken. The music is by Röderer and Klasen. Some listeners singled out its faster, attacking pulse, while others were especially struck by the rhythmic vocals or the construction of the slower passages. The contrasts within the track had belonged to the sound Atrocity wanted to present to the label ever since the advance recording.95, 96

    In the lyrics of Defiance, violence tests the will and seeks to break it; the booklet credits the music to Röderer and Scharf. Several later listeners remembered its rhythmic structure and solo, while one reviewer’s interest flagged at this very track. The next song, Triumph at Dawn, has the same musical authors, but its lyrics move through images of combat towards the overthrow of tyranny. For some, the acceleration gave the song its force; others found it simpler and less substantial than the strongest parts of the record. Through shifting tempos and two different narratives of resistance, the first five tracks thus arrive at the central transition.97, 98

    During the minute and a half of Introduction, the album’s sound turns in a new direction before Sky Turned Red begins. The partly Latin text is credited to Krull and the arrangement to Atrocity. In the next track, Krull wrote the story of someone remembering among ruins, set to music by Scharf and Röderer; Sky Turned Red had already appeared on the advance recording. The singer later recalled how the demo differed from the final sound, and mentioned Wagner when discussing classical influences. Some listeners heard this connection at the boundary between the transition and the choral-like passage; one review drew a parallel with Götterdämmerung. For others, the decisive contrast was between the slow, doom-laden chorus and the sharply articulated verses. No specific, identified passage in a score has been established.99, 100

    Necropolis moves from an image of human destruction towards the graveyard. Different listeners noticed the solo and the chorus in Scharf and Röderer’s song; sudden changes of tempo also disrupt its more direct death-metal structure. A Prison Called Earth then expands confinement to encompass all earthly existence. At the start of Röderer’s composition, one later reviewer of the demo heard keyboard chords giving way to a heavy guitar sound, followed by a closing riff that gradually slows down. The guest vocals, however, divided listeners: one wished the operatic part had been brought more prominently to the foreground.101, 102

    Röderer’s opening theme returns in the tenth piece. The reprise has a track of its own, so the musical frame remains recognisable even if the listener has mainly concentrated on individual guitars or drums until that point. On cassette and vinyl, the programme ends here. The eleven-track CD, however, also revisits something of the scene from which the band had chosen the studio for its first album. The music of Archangel is by Chuck Schuldiner. The detailed printed credits separately record Krull’s lyrics and Atrocity’s adaptation. Krull discussed the cover directly with Schuldiner and later spoke of lyrics that had been partially rewritten.103, 104

    Gianna Possehl brought dark, dried roses to the cover. Beside the roses in the booklet appeared a German aphorism attributed to Arthur Schopenhauer: if the dead were asked whether they wished to return, they would shake their heads. Christian Bruch’s five separate portraits of the musicians placed unmistakably human faces alongside the music in the same release. The German inscription is visible in a band above the roses on the cover. On the American edition, the same position carried the words Longing for Death.105

    In Copenhagen, a fanzine interviewer tried to render the title with the word Deathwish. Krull mentioned the American form Longing for Death and explained how much was lost when the German word was confined to a single short English expression. By 2004, he also said that the English inscription had been used against the band’s wishes. Later he invoked Expressionist literature, memories of the wars and the darker, poetic expressive power of the German language when attempting to explain why he had insisted on the original.106

    In 1992, German shops sold 131.8 million CDs, compared with 104.2 million the previous year. Cassette sales fell from 78.4 to 58.2 million, and vinyl records from 23.8 to 5.1 million. In a later Bundestag summary, CDs accounted for 74 per cent of sales value, up from 62 per cent the previous year. DCC and MiniDisc also reached shops that year. A cassette sent through the post, meanwhile, could carry something that often existed neither on CD nor in any other commercially available format: a demo, rehearsal, concert or compilation assembled by another fan.107

    In the recollections of Dima Andreyuk and Mark Riddick, the cassette travelled with an envelope, address and letter. A fanzine reached the same listener by another route. There was a great difference in editing time and distribution strength between a telephone interview with Atrocity in a small publication and a review in the nationally circulated Rock Hard or Metal Hammer. For the band, each was a chance to say something about the album beyond what its cover and label could convey. In those years, Nuclear Blast, Century Media, Roadrunner and Massacre, considered to have been founded in 1991, began working with heavy music on different scales. The first Atrocity tapes and later multiple editions stood at opposite ends of that changing distribution network.108

    Small but important differences remained between the physical editions. On Roadrunner’s European CD, both RR 9128. 2 and RR 9128 2 appear as variants of the catalogue number. The back cover gives a playing time of 47:22, whereas the individual times listed in the database total 47:15. For Defiance, the database’s songwriting information differs from the original booklet, which names Röderer and Scharf. The American RRD 9128 CD also uses the English title, while Archangel is absent from the ten-track cassette and LP programmes. In the shared sequence of the first ten tracks, the record returns to the melody with which it began.109

    The album reached several territories and formats in 1992. European Roadracer and Roadrunner vinyl editions, regular and promotional cassettes, and US cassette and CD editions appear in the catalogues, along with Polish Metal Mind and Thai Roadrunner cassettes. Later the story continued in further formats: Metal Mind issued a numbered, remastered CD in 2007, and Massacre prepared new vinyl editions in 2020. The database also distinguishes two European Roadrunner repressings without dates.110

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    09 / 10

    Two Calendars

    In the history of the band, 1992 was the year of the Roadrunner album. A later data listing gives 22 September as its release date. On the evidence of primary release materials, the year is certain. The concert list already takes the group to Paris on 19 October. After shows in the Netherlands and Belgium come Stockholm and Copenhagen, then Berlin, Hamburg, Ludwigsburg and Munich. Later autumn dates also include Poland, Austria, Italy, Spain and Britain. The Rockfabrik appears as the home stop on the European tour, the place where Krull had organised his first festival a few years earlier.111, 112

    Later release catalogues date Atrocity’s second album to Tuesday, 22 September 1992. They also date the US Metal Blade CD edition of Cannibal Corpse’s Tomb of the Mutilated to that same day. The release dates of these two very different-sounding death-metal records thus meet on the pages of retrospective catalogues; their coincidence sketches the musical paths coexisting within the genre at the time.133

    The changes in the September weather are particularly clear in readings from the Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg measuring station. On 22 September the maximum temperature reached 27.7 degrees Celsius, the sun shone for more than nine hours, and precipitation amounted to 3.4 millimetres. One day later, on 23 September, the temperature reached only 18.3 degrees, sunshine lasted less than an hour, and 1.6 millimetres of rain were measured. The contrasting readings for those two days survive in a local republication of DWD-derived data.134

    A contemporary advertisement in EB/METRONOM gives 27–30 November for the dates in Berlin, Hamburg, Ludwigsburg and Munich. Alongside the names Deicide, Unleashed, Atrocity and Malevolent Creation, the printed notice supplied exactly what audiences needed at the time: where and when the concert would take place. Today’s concert list places several venues in those same cities at the end of October instead. For Warsaw, even the day differs between accounts. A concert date announced in advance and a sequence of events assembled afterwards are two distinct traces of the tour.113

    In Copenhagen, a contributor to Nagual spoke with Krull on the occasion of a show with Deicide and Gorefest. According to the editor, the conversation was recorded outside in a noisy environment. They also asked about restrictions on stage diving. Krull made clear that he himself was not opposed to the audience’s practice. Performances continued the following year: the list records Karlsruhe with Morgoth in March, German and Swiss dates with Dark Millennium in April, and Kölleda with Pyogenesis in June.114

    Atrocity undertook the tour after completing their second album. The editor of Aberration spoke with Krull after a show in Paris; the singer felt that their performance that evening had been less successful because they were tired, and recalled various audience reactions. This immediate, close-up impression suggests a more varied reception than might be inferred from the album’s later reputation.115

    An early review from 1993 already focused on the shift between the two Atrocity albums: in the reviewer’s view, death, grind and doom had become more closely interwoven than on the debut. Later, an undated review emphasised how musical themes transformed into one another. Fast, single-note runs give way to chords; several guitar lines proceed simultaneously; explosive vocals are held together by precise drumming. This critic did not overlook the production’s limitations, yet still singled out the large-scale musical ideas and the quieter vocal solutions as noteworthy.116

    In the new millennium, the early album increasingly became the standard against which Atrocity’s later changes were judged. A reviewer of the Taste of Sin single began from an admiration for Longing for Death; he heard a partial return on Willenskraft and yet another change of direction on Werk 80. Other retrospective reviewers focused not on these turns in the band’s career but on the internal atmosphere of Todessehnsucht. One considered the technical weight of Unspoken Names and A Prison Called Earth a reinforcement of its dark frame. Another listener, however, admired the musicians’ skill and dangerous tempos while finding that the contrasting moods of the record did not always form a unified whole.117

    On forums and music databases in the 2000s, listeners increasingly tried to put individual details into words. One considered the alternation of thrash-like riffs, blast beats, slow atmospheric passages and independent bass ideas a strength of the album; another found its complexity an obstacle on first hearing. Later, that second listener came to appreciate Michael Schwarz’s precision and the internal order of the slower sections, but would have preferred the guest singers to have more room. Celtic Frost was raised as an earlier example of placing operatic and extreme vocals side by side. In a third interpretation, the return of the opening motif, as much as the sombre atmosphere and riffs, lent the album cohesion.118

    Attention also turned over time towards instrumental details. A reviewer writing in 2013 followed the music through subtle excursions of the snare, toms and bass; Krull’s vocals reminded him of Napalm Death’s Harmony Corruption era. A 2011 article identified the roles of bass and drums as the key to following the unconventional guitar passages. Comparisons with Florida death metal and German thrash recurred in several places, though with different emphases: some highlighted the rhythm section’s steadiness, whereas a review from 2018 heard the leading motif of the opening track running through almost the entire album. The latter compared the scope of the undertaking to Atheist’s Unquestionable Presence and At the Gates’ The Red in the Sky Is Ours.119

    The drying roses on the cover led many people to expect a different musical world. Recalling his first encounter with the record in a shop in 1992, one writer in 2018 said the image alone had been enough to make him pick it up; later, A Prison Called Earth became the defining track for him, whereas Defiance convinced him less. A forum contributor in 2026 had long judged Atrocity by Die Liebe, the collaboration with Das Ich, and had kept away from the band as a result. Seeing the later gothic image and the cover of Todessehnsucht, he expected a stronger death–doom presence, but ultimately heard the slower and melodic parts as less common, and death metal as more dominant. He considered it a decent album, but doubted he would return to it soon.120

    Alongside the disc, the image of the release travelled to different places. The roses and the thought in the booklet about returning after death approached, from another direction, the same theme that the opening verse marked with a leaf separating from its branch. Someone could see the photograph before ever hearing the unusual rhythms, operatic singing or the opening idea returning on the tenth track. Those whose first expectations were set by the cover could have their own answer by the end of the record.121, 122

    ← Previous chapterNext chapter →Beginning of bookBack to top
    10 / 10

    Memories That Became Part of the Album

    In 2012, Krull recalled an incident in Augsburg in which, according to him, youth-protection officials interpreted the word Todessehnsucht as an exhortation and initiated action to stop the album launch. Among the public recollections of those involved, it is the singer’s version that has survived. In Copenhagen, this same word had been difficult to translate; in Augsburg, he said, it threatened consequences far beyond the album’s music.123

    After the early death-metal period, Atrocity’s records turned towards increasingly different sounds. Blut sought darker images in 1994; later recollections in Die Gottlosen Jahre preserved the Transylvanian legends and the video shoot as a story of their own. Calling the Rain gave a greater role to different voices and arrangements, while by the time of Willenskraft electronic tools and new studio methods had come to the fore; Werk 80 then took the band towards cover versions. Many continued to measure these changes against the 1992 album. A critic who favoured the early death-metal era therefore found the new works harder to follow, while other listeners remained open to Blut and Calling the Rain after the dark atmosphere of Todessehnsucht.124, 125

    By the time of Atlantis in 2004, Krull looked back on the first two full-length albums as parts of a long, experimental career. His interviewer, Tosso Bauer, meanwhile brought the experience of a later line-up into the conversation. According to Krull, a new task began to take shape around 2007: collecting old photographs and films from former members, acquaintances and collaborators. Die Gottlosen Jahre was originally intended to be shorter, but eventually ran for several hours, and even then could not contain every story. The memory of Todessehnsucht (1992) continued to appear in a new light in subsequent interviews: Expressionist literature was emphasised in 2018, the four demo songs in 2022 and the title changed into English in 2023.126

    The four recordings from 1991 survived beyond the album. Krull preserved the tapes at Mastersound. Unspoken Names became available first, while its companions had to wait longer. The full material was originally scheduled for release in November 2021, but disruptions to vinyl manufacturing during the pandemic delayed it until January 2022. Krull described the remaster as a refresh, because he had valued the sound of the original recording even at the time. A later reviewer listened to the same four tracks through their keyboard introductions, tight drumming and subtle differences from the album versions. What had been one of the preconditions for the next album in 1991 showed in 2022 just how much had already been ready before the label made its decision.127, 128

    The title melody must wait until track ten to sound again under its own name. By then the structures of other songs, human voices and tempos have intervened. After the reprise, the CD offers another piece drawn from elsewhere, while the shorter album ends where it has found its way back to its beginning. Along the edge of the booklet, Fautspach, Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg remain in the same order. When the music returns to its opening theme, we know how much has happened between those three names.129, 130

    ← Previous chapterEnd of the bookBeginning of bookBack to top

    Sources and references · 134

    The notes below present the supporting sources together with source-critical explanations. Each superscript reference in the narrative opens its own detailed note page.

    Historical and documentary notes · 117

    001. The original 1992 CD booklet’s studio credits and Krull’s recollections of the recording

    Related passage: The Names in the Margin of the Booklet — Three place names appear close together in the booklet accompanying the first edition of Todessehnsucht

    Documented supporting details: Page 2 of the original 1992 Roadrunner CD booklet identifies three distinct stages of production: Mainstreet Studio, Fautspach (recording); Daylight Studios, Stuttgart (mixing); and Bauer Studios, Ludwigsburg (mastering). The credits provide primary evidence of the work undertaken and the locations, but do not specify the exact number of days spent recording or mixing. According to a statement by Alex Krull from the period, the band spent around four weeks recording the album at the studio used for the promotional cassette, then another two weeks mixing the material at a different location in Stuttgart.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Underground Empire, 1991
    3. Aberration, 1993
    4. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: The contemporary interview is a statement reported by a participant or journalist. Personal recollections, future plans and approximate figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-company or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    002. Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg as sites of musical history — the album studios of a later era

    Related passage: The Names in the Margin of the Booklet — According to the printed credits, recording began in the wooded countryside around Fautspach

    Documented supporting details: The written reference to an organ at Stuttgart’s Stiftskirche in 1381, together with the organisation of Württemberg court music, points to a distinct historical layer in these locations. Drawing a musical-historical parallel between them is a narrative choice; it does not imply that the band selected its studios because of that history. The alternating locations of the Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg courts also form part of the region’s eighteenth-century development. Cooperation between court musicians and canons can be documented in the fifteenth century, and by 1495 the Württemberg court chapel employed singers, choirboys, trumpeters and other instrumentalists.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview
    2. Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · La Didone abbandonata (Stuttgart 1763) – Niccolò Jommelli · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg / Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · Specialist historical account; covering 1753–1769
    3. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen – a history of Ludwigsburg · Stadt Ludwigsburg – municipal administration · 1704–1992 (overview of local history; online publication date not specified)
    4. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · Municipal historical overview
    5. Underground Empire, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details presented as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    003. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte — the official Stuttgart historical overview

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The oldest layer of the story leads to the Neckar

    Documented supporting details: The historical overview published by the City of Stuttgart identifies a Roman fort at Bad Cannstatt, in a bend of the Neckar, dating to around AD 90. It treats the foundation of a stud farm around 950, traditionally associated with Liudolf, as a tradition rather than a securely documented founding event. The twelfth-century reference to the place name and the development of municipal rights in the thirteenth century belong to different historical periods. The relocation of the counts’ residence and burial site in the early fourteenth century also affected architecture and urban development around the Stiftskirche. This is local historical background, not Atrocity’s personal musical history.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21
    2. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    004. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen — a history of Ludwigsburg

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — On 7 May 1704, Eberhard Ludwig began building a palace

    Documented supporting details: The appeal offered prospective settlers near the palace plots of land and building materials, together with time-limited relief from public levies. Duke Eberhard Ludwig of Württemberg initially intended to build a palace at Erlachhof suitable merely for hunting and summer stays; construction of the residential palace began in 1704. The account distinguishes three dates of particular importance to the development of the town: 1704, when the foundation stone of the residential palace was laid; 1709, when Eberhard Ludwig issued his first appeal to attract settlers; and 3 September 1718, when a ducal rescript conferred urban status and the rank of residence and third capital of Württemberg. As an additional incentive, Eberhard Ludwig called on his administrative districts to construct official buildings, which he gave to his favourites. The administrative apparatus and court patronage also contributed to the town’s growth.

    Source details:

    1. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen – a history of Ludwigsburg · Stadt Ludwigsburg – municipal administration · 1704–1992 (local-history overview; online publication date not specified)
    2. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)
    3. Stadt geworden! – selection of sources on the granting of town status · Stadtarchiv Ludwigsburg / municipal publications · 2018 (digital presentation of urban history)
    4. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    005. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen — a history of Ludwigsburg

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The regular streets, marketplace and distinctive townhouses gradually gave Ludwigsburg an urban form; for a long time, however, livelihoods depended on whether the court was present or absent

    Documented supporting details: With the court present again between 1764 and 1775, the population reached 11,607 in 1774; its departure was followed by another steep decline (PDF pp. 52–53). According to the study, the population stood at 600 in 1718 and 5,668 in 1733, but fell to about 2,443 after the court moved back in 1733 (PDF p. 51, printed p. 53). Following Eberhard Ludwig’s death, half the population left the town because his successor, Carl Alexander, governed from Stuttgart. This figure is a retrospective, approximate statement by the museum, not a directly verified household census from the time. In 1764, Carl Eugen again chose Ludwigsburg as his residence and expanded the original town with Carlsstadt.

    Source details:

    1. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen – a history of Ludwigsburg · Stadt Ludwigsburg – municipal administration · 1704–1992 (local-history overview; online publication date not specified)
    2. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)
    3. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    006. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte — the official Stuttgart historical overview

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Württemberg became a duchy in 1495

    Documented supporting details: During the Thirty Years’ War of 1618–1648, the population of Stuttgart fell, according to the source’s estimate, from roughly ten thousand to approximately 4,500. This resulted from the combined effects of military burdens and epidemics. Württemberg’s elevation to a duchy in 1495 was followed by the sixteenth-century Reformation and Renaissance. In local historical memory, the Thirty Years’ War and epidemics caused severe devastation in the municipality; the source mentions that Schöllhütte was completely depopulated for a time, without specifying a year.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21
    2. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · municipal historical overview

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    007. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The canons from Beutelsbach came to Stuttgart around 1321

    Documented supporting details: The source names Sebastian Virdung and, in the early sixteenth century, Heinrich Finck among the leading figures of early court music. The community of canons from Beutelsbach was moved to Stuttgart around 1321; the first secure evidence of an organ at the Stiftskirche dates to 1381.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    008. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — In 1618, the establishment comprised five musicians alongside a music master

    Documented supporting details: According to the source, the Stiftsmusik institution was founded in 1618, initially with one master and five musicians, among other duties to accompany church singing. The Thirty Years’ War, and particularly the Battle of Nördlingen in 1634, brought financial decline. From the 1650s, the work of Philipp Friedrich Boeddecker and the installation of a new organ mark a local revival of polychoral and instrumental church music.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    009. Music at the Ludwigsburg court — Jommelli and Noverre

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — In 1728, the orchestra was moved to Ludwigsburg

    Documented supporting details: The Académie des Arts, established in Ludwigsburg in 1761, and the Württemberg court opera were major cultural institutions. According to the source, Niccolò Jommelli’s appointment as an opera conductor was associated with the ducal court from 1754; during the 1750s and 1760s he composed and presented large-scale theatrical and sacred works. Under Carl Eugen, theatre, opera, ballet and musical training expanded, notably through the work of Niccolò Jommelli and ballet master J. G. Noverre. Under the two rulers, Eberhard Ludwig and Carl Eugen, the palace served as a Württemberg residence for a combined total of 28 years. This is an aggregate duration, not a continuous stay by both rulers during the same years. In 1764, Carl Eugen again chose Ludwigsburg as his residence and extended the original town with Carlsstadt.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview
    2. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)
    3. Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · La Didone abbandonata (Stuttgart 1763) – Niccolò Jommelli · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg / Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · Specialist historical account; covering 1753–1769

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    010. Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer — the third Stuttgart version of 1763

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Preparations were under way in Stuttgart for Carl Eugen’s thirty-fifth birthday on 11 February 1763.

    Documented supporting details: The third Stuttgart version was performed at the Hoftheater on 11 February 1763, Duke Carl Eugen’s thirty-fifth birthday. The ending gave way to the ballet “La Gloria e il trionfo di Nettuno”, choreographed by Jean Georges Noverre with music by Florian Deller, which was associated with the evening’s gala dinner.

    Source details:

    1. Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · La Didone abbandonata (Stuttgart 1763) – Niccolò Jommelli · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg / Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · Specialist historical account; covering 1753–1769

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    011. Die Gemeinde Althütte — the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The earliest reasonably secure written reference in the municipal history preserving Sechselberg’s past is the charter from 1027, from the reign of Conrad II

    Documented supporting details: The earliest recorded references to the settlements vary in age: Lutzenberg in 1407, Kallenberg in 1408 and Schöllhütte in 1459. Althütte was established as an independent municipality only in 1819, then including the constituent settlements of Lutzenberg, Kallenberg, Nonnenmühle and Voggenhof. Until that point it belonged to the administrative and judicial system associated with Unterweissach.

    Source details:

    1. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · municipal historical overview

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    012. Die Gemeinde Althütte — the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — In Andreas Kieser’s depiction from 1686, the village appears under the name Fautsbach

    Documented supporting details: Many families carved rakes at home and sold them through itinerant trade; an account citing a church document from 1855 mentions about 40,000 rakes produced. In local historical memory, the Thirty Years’ War and epidemics caused severe devastation; the source reports that Schöllhütte was completely abandoned for a period, without providing a precise year. A separate section on the history of glassmaking discusses former furnaces and the suffix “Hütte” in local place names. Glassmaking had genuinely been an earlier source of livelihood, and the names of several nearby settlements likewise reflect this historical division of labour. The museum displays of a rake-making workshop, a subsequently added wheelwright’s workshop and a historical exhibition in the former classroom help illuminate the combined economic history of manual work, tool use and agricultural life.

    Source details:

    1. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · municipal historical overview
    2. Fautsbach: Sechselberg, Althütte – archival depiction from 1686 · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg, Hauptstaatsarchiv Stuttgart · 1686 (original cartographic/pictorial source)
    3. Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks, local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · 1988 museum opening and earlier local history

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    013. Heimat-Museum Althütte — work, glassworks and local water supply; museum opened in 1988

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Anna Haag, the teacher’s daughter, was born on 10 July 1888 in the Althütte schoolhouse built in 1873

    Documented supporting details: The Heimat-Museum opened on 30 April 1988 in the former school building erected in 1873. Its website points to an important aspect of constitutional history: the idea of legal protection against being compelled to perform armed military service, which Anna Haag had advocated in Württemberg-Baden, entered Article 4(3) of the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949 in modified wording, as protection for conscientious objection to armed service.

    Source details:

    1. Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks, local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · 1988 museum opening and earlier local history

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    014. Heimat-Museum Althütte — work, glassworks and local water supply

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Piped water came from the forest too

    Documented supporting details: In Fautspach, the historic Lambach water pump used the combined flow of 0.77 litres per second from two Ochsenhau springs; according to the museum’s account, the device supplied water through pipes from 1929. From 1937, the second installation, near Nonnenmühle in the Strümpfelbachtal nature conservation area, played a role in Althütte’s water supply, with a capacity of 63 litres per minute.

    Source details:

    1. Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks, local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · 1988 museum opening and earlier local history
    2. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · municipal historical overview
    3. BKZ – article author unidentified · Holpriger Start in eine gemeinsame Zukunft – Fautspach/Sechselberg municipal reform · Backnanger Kreiszeitung (BKZ) · 2021 (retrospective article on the events of 1971–1972)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    015. Die Gemeinde Althütte — the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Of the votes cast in Sechselberg on 23 May 1971, more than 58 per cent favoured a merger with Althütte

    Documented supporting details: The Sechselberg council also held talks at the time with Althütte, Murrhardt and municipalities in the Weissacher Tal; the eventual decision therefore did not simply follow an earlier consensus. A public consultation was held in Sechselberg and its constituent settlements on 23 May 1971, when more than 58 per cent of votes cast favoured Althütte. On 27 May 1971, the mayors Walter Sipple of Althütte and Peter Beck of Sechselberg signed the merger agreement at the Rößle inn in Waldenweiler. According to former Sechselberg councillor Gotthold Muff, local communities did not all look towards the same centre: part of Sechselberg was oriented towards the Weissacher Tal, another part towards Althütte; Fautspach tended to look towards Murrhardt, while Waldenweiler was divided. Present-day Althütte came into being on 1 July 1971, when the previously independent municipalities of Althütte and Sechselberg merged voluntarily.

    Source details:

    1. Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · municipal historical overview
    2. BKZ – article author unidentified · Holpriger Start in eine gemeinsame Zukunft – Fautspach/Sechselberg municipal reform · Backnanger Kreiszeitung (BKZ) · 2021 (retrospective article on the events of 1971–1972)
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, American CD and booklet.

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    016. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — By the time the court finally departed in 1816, the town had to sustain several kinds of livelihood side by side

    Documented supporting details: Local historical and museum accounts describe the foundations of Ludwigsburg’s economic adjustment after it ceased to be a court residence in 1816 through earlier ventures in silk, leather, metalworking and cloth. The clothworks associated with a workhouse and orphanage in 1736–1737 lasted longer, while the porcelain manufactory founded in 1758 survived until 1824. The development of the garrison and its barracks also affected demand in the shops. Local histories may cite different initial years for the construction of barracks (1736) and for the institutional period of the garrison town (1737); the two dates must not be treated as interchangeable.

    Source details:

    1. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968
    2. Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen – a history of Ludwigsburg · Stadt Ludwigsburg – municipal administration · 1704–1992 (local-history overview; online publication date not specified)
    3. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)
    4. Stadt geworden! – selection of sources on the granting of town status · Stadtarchiv Ludwigsburg / municipal publications · 2018 (digital presentation of urban history)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    017. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016 — the railway in 1846

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — For craftsmen in Stuttgart and Ludwigsburg, the lack of raw materials and water power was not the only limit on the size of their workshops; transport mattered too

    Documented supporting details: According to a report in the Ludwigsburger Tagblatt of 1 October 1846, a trial train from Stuttgart reached Ludwigsburg on 30 September; the ceremonial opening took place on 15 October. Construction of the Cannstatt–Untertürkheim–Esslingen railway section was completed in 1845 and that of the Cannstatt–Stuttgart–Ludwigsburg section in October 1846. Bergan describes the government’s preparations from 1836 and the debate over possible routes along the Neckar. Carl Seeger and later Alois Negrelli examined routes associated with an earlier Cannstatt-centred concept, while Karl Etzel’s 1844 plan brought the Stuttgart–Prag–Zuffenhausen–Ludwigsburg axis into focus. Stammheim and Zuffenhausen, for example, belonged to the Ludwigsburg Oberamt, while other areas belonged to Cannstatt or the Stuttgart Amt.

    Source details:

    1. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016
    2. Das S-Bahn Netz im Stuttgarter Raum / frühere industrielle Verkehrsachsen · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart – historical statistics · statistical historical study published in 2009

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    018. Das S-Bahn Netz im Stuttgarter Raum / frühere industrielle Verkehrsachsen

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — With industrialisation, even the districts growing towards the railway did not expand at the same pace

    Documented supporting details: Industrialisation produced sharply differing rates of population growth from settlement to settlement from the mid-nineteenth century onwards. Between 1851 and 1900, the reported increase was approximately 248 per cent in Stuttgart’s historic core as a royal residence, 428 per cent in Gaisburg and 298 per cent in Bad Cannstatt. These are percentages for settlements with different starting populations, not absolute numbers of residents. The Walcker organ-building workshop of 1820, the Nast printing house of 1824, metalworking and weaving businesses and later food-processing plants were concrete stages in the gradual transition from crafts to industry (PDF p. 54). The lasting weight of the military presence is demonstrated by a garrison of 5,113 alongside a civilian population of 22,774 in 1910 (PDF p. 55).

    Source details:

    1. Das S-Bahn Netz im Stuttgarter Raum / frühere industrielle Verkehrsachsen · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart – historical statistics · statistical historical study published in 2009
    2. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968
    3. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    019. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 1968

    Related passage: Workshops and Stations — After the world war, jobs vanished as the garrison was reduced

    Documented supporting details: The Great Depression must not be obscured by a general account of “industrialisation”: the study records 114 industrial enterprises in 1927, 111 in 1930, 109 in 1933 and 98 in 1937 (Schifferer, 1968, printed pp. 70, 73 and 79). The study lists examples of industrial land purchases between 1921 and 1928 on printed pages 59–60, and separately explains the circumstances of the Wüstenrot building society’s relocation to Ludwigsburg in 1928 on printed pages 60–61.

    Source details:

    1. Otto Schifferer · Die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung Ludwigsburgs von der Gründung der Stadt bis zum Beginn des 2. Weltkrieges · Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, Heft 20 (1968), S. 53–80.

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    020. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte — the official Stuttgart historical overview

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The scale of Stuttgart, meanwhile, was changing rapidly

    Documented supporting details: The population figures preserved in the City of Stuttgart’s 2020 historical overview illustrate the growth into a major city in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: from around 91,000 inhabitants in 1871 to approximately 286,000 by 1910. The incorporation of Cannstatt, the opening of the state theatres in 1912, and later the Weissenhof Estate, the Tagblatt Tower and the Schocken department store are architectural and cultural traces of different decades. The source is an institutional retrospective, not an independent population census from the time or a metal-music source.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    021. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Public music in the city could attract audiences in more than one setting

    Documented supporting details: The institutional history of Stiftsmusik describes the foundation of the Liederkranz in 1824, the opening of the Liederhalle in 1864 and the expansion of the city’s concert life. According to the history of the Stuttgarter Musikschule, in February 1857 twenty-two musicians and lovers of music supported the foundation of a music school; teaching began on 15 April under Sigmund Lebert. These details of institutional history bear witness to the widening of bourgeois musical culture; they do not establish a direct musical influence on Atrocity a century later.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview
    2. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    022. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936)

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — From 1896, the Stuttgart school operated under the name Royal Conservatory

    Documented supporting details: From 1896, the institution operated under the name Königliches Konservatorium für Musik in Stuttgart; professional and amateur courses separated in 1921. Professional training continued under the name Württembergische Hochschule für Musik, while the teachers and students of the amateur branch remained within a new conservatory organisation.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    023. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte — the official Stuttgart historical overview

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — After 1933, the dictatorship reshaped factories and administration to serve its own purposes

    Documented supporting details: The air raids of 1944 caused severe devastation and approximately 4,500 deaths, including, according to the source, some 700 forced labourers. The section on the years of National Socialism must neither be omitted nor treated as a cultural backdrop. The city’s website records political and social exclusion, over 500 victims of the so-called “euthanasia” programme, approximately 2,500 Jewish people from Württemberg and Stuttgart deported from late 1941, and numerous Sinti and Roma deported in March 1943.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    024. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg — the town survived the war relatively intact

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — More buildings survived the war in Ludwigsburg

    Documented supporting details: According to the museum, Ludwigsburg survived the war relatively intact. In 1945, French and then American Allied units took control; military buildings also served temporarily as reception and internment facilities. After the loss of the court, the garrison function shaped the town for a long period, followed by twentieth-century industry. The central historical observation is that the urban spaces of the region where Atrocity operated contained successive layers of Baroque heritage, two world wars and military infrastructure, industrialisation and the American presence during the Cold War.

    Source details:

    1. 300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)
    2. Stadtentwicklung Ludwigsburg – from garrison to civilian town, Pattonville and 1970–1990 · Stadt Ludwigsburg / urban development study · around 2011 (historical retrospective)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    025. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte — the official Stuttgart historical overview

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — At the same time, more and more people needed homes

    Documented supporting details: The state of Baden-Württemberg was established in 1952 through the merger of the former Baden, Württemberg-Baden and Württemberg-Hohenzollern. Urbanisation in the first half of the twentieth century was disrupted by wartime losses, displacements and waves of refugees. The author gives approximately 320,000 war deaths, including more than 40,000 civilian casualties, across the territory of the present-day state during the Second World War. These events must appear in the later account of the local period with their actual historical participants, without inventing family relationships or a personal effect on Atrocity. After 1945, Stuttgart’s economy, new municipal administration and public institutions were rebuilt; from 1952 it was the capital of Baden-Württemberg. A new town hall, the Liederhalle and the television tower opened in 1956, while modernisation also led to the demolition of several older historical buildings.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21
    2. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – Baden-Württemberg population history · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    026. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Pattonville, with homes and a school, was built for Americans on the southeastern outskirts of Ludwigsburg in 1954

    Documented supporting details: During the 1950s and 1960s, industrial development and labour shortages were accompanied by the immigration of foreign workers, initially from Italy and later from Yugoslavia, Spain, Portugal and Turkey. Because of the existing barracks, a significant American military presence developed here after the Second World War. In 1954, the Pattonville complex was built on the southeastern outskirts of the town, with a military school and residential neighbourhood.

    Source details:

    1. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016
    2. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – Baden-Württemberg population history · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)
    3. Stadtentwicklung Ludwigsburg – from garrison to civilian town, Pattonville and 1970–1990 · Stadt Ludwigsburg / urban development study · around 2011 (historical retrospective)

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    027. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — The opera singer and teacher Karl Adler was removed from the leadership of the Neues Konservatorium in 1933 because of his Jewish background

    Documented supporting details: The opera singer and educator Karl Adler led the Neues Konservatorium für Musik before being removed from his leadership position in 1933 because he was Jewish. The institution was dissolved and reconstituted under National Socialist leadership; in 1936 it was dissolved again as part of the Gleichschaltung system, and its assets went to a new school operating within the Nazi Kraft durch Freude organisation.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview
    2. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    028. Zeitreise: Festspiele im Schloss – Ludwigsburger Schlossfestspiele

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Regular concerts began at Ludwigsburg Palace in 1932

    Documented supporting details: The state palace administration’s historical timeline traces the origins of the Schlossfestspiele to concerts held at Ludwigsburg Palace from 1932. After the Second World War, a total of 34 concerts took place in 1947 as part of Schlosskonzerte/Mozart-Tage, not on a single evening. The institutional history of Stuttgart’s music school is a separate thread: youth courses began in 1951 and adult courses in 1953; in 1968 they became a single organisation, and from 1976 they were run by the municipality. The development of these two institutions forms parallel historical background; they were not one institution.

    Source details:

    1. Zeitreise: Festspiele im Schloss – Ludwigsburger Schlossfestspiele · Staatliche Schlösser und Gärten Baden-Württemberg · historical data for 1932 and 1947
    2. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    029. Total Normahl — punk in the Winnenden/Stuttgart region; a ticket preserved from 1977

    Related passage: Court, City, Forest — Hans-Peter Haag dates one of his first concerts, with the band Erna Schmidt, to October 1971

    Documented supporting details: A ticket preserved to this day identifies an AC/DC concert at the Gustav-Siegle-Haus on 28 September 1977. Drawing on first-hand recollections, the document presents the career of concert promoter Hans-Peter Haag, including the “Erna Schmidt” concert held in a Catholic community hall in Stuttgart in October 1971, detailing the practical and financial conditions of local concert promotion in the early 1970s. In the personal account recalled there, after Dan Peter’s experience of English punk in 1976, a band was already forming under the name The Beauties around the Fanny-Leicht-Gymnasium in Stuttgart in 1977.

    Source details:

    1. Total Normahl – punk in the Winnenden/Stuttgart region · Region Stuttgart · 2015-05-07
    2. Meister seines Fachs – Hans-Peter Haag, Music Circus · Region Stuttgart · later profile, around 2015
    3. Wie der Punk nach Stuttgart kam – press archive · Stuttgartpunk.de / Simon Steiner research project · 2017 collection page and secondary reproductions

    Source-critical limits: Local historical, archival or institutional accounts describe the region’s documented past; they do not demonstrate any direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details handed down as tradition must not be presented as certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    030. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — After the oil crises, unemployment appeared in figures that made it difficult to discern the earlier pace of economic growth

    Documented supporting details: According to Schildt, the unemployment rate in West Germany stood at 2.6 per cent in 1974 and 4.7 per cent in 1975, then fell to 3.8 per cent in 1979–1980 during a temporary easing; after the second oil crisis, it reached 7.5 per cent in 1982. The Greens won just 1.5 per cent in the 1980 federal election, but entered the Bundestag with 5.6 per cent in 1983.

    Source details:

    1. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989 · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · Overview published around 2002; covering the years 1970–1989

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    031. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — The German Autumn of 1977 brought Stuttgart-Stammheim into the national headlines as well

    Documented supporting details: In response to the deployment of Soviet SS–20 missiles towards the end of the 1970s, NATO simultaneously adopted, in December 1979, provisions for deploying intermediate-range weapons in Western Europe and the possibility of negotiations over those weapons. The history of domestic security also includes the armed far-left terrorist groups of the 1970s, among them the RAF, and the events of 1977 known as the “German Autumn”.

    Source details:

    1. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989 · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · Overview published around 2002; covering the years 1970–1989
    2. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    032. Wie der Punk nach Stuttgart kam – press collection

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — Stuttgart punk’s early years, from 1977 to 1983, could not be contained within the walls of a single club

    Documented supporting details: The emerging network also extended towards Stuttgart, Tübingen, Ludwigsburg, Böblingen and Pforzheim. According to the article, Steiner interviewed nearly 120 former participants over three years and examined fanzines, concert flyers, records, tapes and photographs from Stuttgart’s punk scene of 1977–1983.

    Source details:

    1. Wie der Punk nach Stuttgart kam – press collection · Stuttgartpunk.de / Simon Steiner research project · 2017 collection page and secondary reproductions

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    033. Ox-Fanzine editorial staff — CHAOS Z: an interview about Stuttgart’s punk/new-wave scene

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — Normahl’s first performance at the Karls-Gymnasium is dated to 1978

    Documented supporting details: Some of the venues for punk performances in the area are described as youth centres and alternative spaces. A performance by Chaos Z at Stuttgart’s Mausefalle on 19 January 1983 is recalled as their farewell concert, at which songs later associated with Fliehende Stürme were already performed. Their first concert in 1980 is linked to a youth centre in Sindelfingen and a Normahl/Fehlprodukt event. The article describes the band Normahl’s 1978 performance at Stuttgart’s Karls-Gymnasium as the beginning of the group from the Winnenden area. These two brief sources can be read alongside each other, but cannot be merged without verification: the Ox-Fanzine interview with Chaos Z records Andreas Löhr’s personal recollection of sharing a bill with Normahl in 1980, whereas the Region Stuttgart article identifies Normahl’s earlier initial performance in 1978.

    Source details:

    1. Ox-Fanzine editorial staff · CHAOS Z – interview about Stuttgart’s punk/new-wave scene · Ox-Fanzine #153 · Online interview from around 2020 (exact publication date unknown)
    2. Total Normahl – punk from the Winnenden/Stuttgart region · Region Stuttgart · 2015-05-07

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    034. SKEEZICKS – Als Hardcore neu war — Ox-Fanzine #159

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — For Armin Hofmann, memories of the clubs and youth centres around Nagold and Tübingen were intertwined with the stories of Skeezicks and X-Mist

    Documented supporting details: According to Hofmann, his brother began early experiments with home recordings using tape machines and homemade instruments; later, a fanzine called ExtremMist developed in the Tübingen/Nagold area, followed by a network of cassette-label and postal contacts known as X-Mist. Hofmann regarded Nagold’s position on a route between the concert networks of northern Italy and Amsterdam as important for the movements of touring hardcore bands.

    Source details:

    1. SKEEZICKS – Als Hardcore neu war · Ox-Fanzine #159 · Online interview from around 2021

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    035. Geschichte der Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg — Thomas Müller (later known as Filimonova) and Udo Heller opened the Longhorn in 1984

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — On 30 November 1983, Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik opened in the hall of a former refrigerator factory.

    Documented supporting details: Thomas Müller (later known as Filimonova) and Udo Heller opened the club on 2 March 1984, originally as a country-and-western saloon; according to the institution’s account, it was an important meeting place for American military personnel stationed around Stuttgart. The Rockfabrik’s institutional history gives 30 November 1983 as the opening date, in a hall that had belonged to a refrigerator factory; it describes a rock centre rather than a conventional disco and points to contacts maintained with magazines, agencies and labels. In its own account of its success, the venue emphasises cooperation with music magazines (Metal Hammer, Rock Hard, Heavy), record labels, concert agencies, bands and managers.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Official history of the venue
    2. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history
    3. Bericht über 20 Jahre Longhorn · LKA Longhorn – archive · Later venue-history account (2004)
    4. Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg – Geschichte: institutional history · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg – official local-history page · Online publication date unknown; discusses the institution’s founding in 1983
    5. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    036. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936)

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — In Ludwigsburg in 1985, a new loud band could already rehearse close to several different audiences

    Documented supporting details: An especially important personal and participant account concerns tour organisation. According to Krull, he staged his first underground festival at Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik in October 1989; he was planning a second for June 1990, with Carcass as the intended headliner. This does not establish which day Atrocity played the Longhorn, what sounds they heard there or whom they met. His account of the reception of unusual music and the good atmosphere on the tour with Sodom is based on his experience; audiences sometimes seemed puzzled, but he also related that reaction to the music’s originality. This is a specifically documented cultural and institutional process and must not be smoothed into a vague story of “continuous development”. Music education changed again after 1945: a youth music school began in 1951, classes for older pupils and adults followed in 1953, and the two merged in 1968 into the Stuttgarter Musikschule e.V.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page
    2. Geschichte der Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Official history of the venue
    3. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history
    4. Peardrop, 1990
    5. Underground Empire, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    037. Holocaust, 1991 or 1992

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — The first line-up began in thrash and used the name Instigator

    Documented supporting details: According to Krull, the band’s original name was Instigator; when they adopted the name Atrocity, they did not know there was a British punk band of that name. On page 53, Alex Krull describes the early Instigators period as originally less technical and more thrash-oriented, and places the major change around 1988, following alterations in personnel and direction. He speaks of an intention to combine the complexity associated with Watchtower and Coroner in technical death metal with the heaviness of Napalm Death and Morbid Angel; this cannot be read as an exhaustive list of personal influences for every band member. According to his own account, the band formed as Instigator in 1985; in response to the question he lists the members at the time (Alex Krull, Matze Röderer, Richard Scharf, Oli Klasen, Migge Schwarz), then refers to the seven-inch single and Hallucinations.

    Source details:

    1. Holocaust, 1991 or 1992
    2. Slayer, 1991
    3. Blasphemous, 1991
    4. Nagual, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    038. Peardrop, 1990

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — Mathias Röderer, or Matze as he was called in conversations, began his explanation of the change by saying that he and Alex had wanted faster, more brutal music, and needed to find others who shared that ambition…

    Documented supporting details: Matze stresses that this was not an entirely new sound, but the logical development of earlier efforts: he and Alex had wanted faster, more brutal music, but finding others with the same ambitions was difficult. According to his own account, the band formed as Instigator in 1985; in response to the question he lists the members at the time (Alex Krull, Matze Röderer, Richard Scharf, Oli Klasen, Migge Schwarz), then refers to the seven-inch single and Hallucinations. He also mentions the former drummer Migge, who sought an individual, unconventional sound, and the new bassist OLI, who had, according to the statement, played with them since February 1989. The surviving credits read: “Mathias Röderer, Richard Scharf and Oliver Klasen play Gibson and Steinberger guitars and bass guitars exclusively.”

    Source details:

    1. Peardrop, 1990
    2. Blasphemous, 1991
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    039. Melanie Arndt — according to Schildt, the Chernobyl reactor disaster of 1986

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — On 26 April 1986, a reactor at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant exploded.

    Documented supporting details: According to Schildt, the Chernobyl reactor disaster of 26 April 1986 marked a turning point, increasing fears of radioactive danger and public opposition to nuclear energy; while the Federal Republic established a separate federal environment ministry. On 28 April, readings by instruments at the Forsmark nuclear power plant in Sweden brought news of the accident to wider attention in Western Europe.

    Source details:

    1. Melanie Arndt · Auswirkungen der Katastrophe von Tschernobyl auf Deutschland · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2016-04-18 (retrospective); events of 1986

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    040. Maastricht Treaty – the founding treaty of the later EU — the latter in 1987

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — On 1 July 1987, the Single European Act, signed the previous year, entered into force.

    Documented supporting details: The latter came into force on 1 July 1987, moving the Communities towards the single market, broader possibilities for majority decisions and greater influence for parliament. Particular turning points in twentieth-century transport included the new railway-station signalling installation of 17 August 1978; the Stuttgart-Schwabstraße–Ludwigsburg S-Bahn service starting on 1 October 1978; the S4 extension to Marbach on 27 September 1980; the S5 to Bietigheim on 30 May 1981; and the central bus station and accessible Franck pedestrian bridge opened on 8 October 1987 (printed p. 160). The old railway station building was demolished in October 1987; the city authorised a new structure in November 1990, and work finally began in May 1991, with DIBAG eventually taking over from the original developer. The Heimat-Museum opened on 30 April 1988 in the former school building erected in 1873.

    Source details:

    1. Maastricht Treaty – founding treaty of the later EU · European Union – official founding agreements · 1992-02-07 (signed), 1993-11-01 (entered into force)
    2. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016
    3. Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks and local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · Museum founded in 1988 and earlier local historical data

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    041. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — While the western part of the country debated economic and social questions, people involved in peace and environmental movements had already gained a presence within institutions

    Documented supporting details: Amid the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan in 1979, martial law in Poland in 1981 and the Reagan era in the United States, West German governments continued trying to preserve institutional links with East Germany. Gradual connections developed between local peaceful civic participation, organising against ecological risks and the emerging Green political movement. An analysis of East Germany’s economic situation, dated 30 October 1989 and intended for the Politburo of the Socialist Unity Party of Germany, offers direct documentary evidence of the economic dimension of the state crisis; the present gallery caption does NOT provide the economic figures or the precise conclusions of that analysis.

    Source details:

    1. Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989 · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · Overview published around 2002; covering the years 1970–1989
    2. Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90 · Bundesarchiv · Events of 1989–1990; later official archival presentation

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    042. Die harten Anfänge: METAL HAMMER in den Achtzigern

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — In 1986, Metallica and Slayer records appeared in the pages of the same music press that taught listeners to argue about speed, vocals and drum sounds

    Documented supporting details: Kreator’s Pleasure to Kill, from the Essen band, is interpreted as one of the most extreme manifestations of the period’s sound and a borderline case pointing towards later death metal. The author recalls Mille Petrozza’s dissatisfaction with the previous producer, Horst Müller, and subsequently Harris Johns’s work on the Pleasure to Kill recording. Fischer explains the stylistic novelty of 1987’s Into the Pandemonium through the inclusion of female and operatic vocals, horn, violin and cellos, and instrumental colours beyond metal. He regarded this as unusual within the extreme metal of the period; in a retrospective from 2010 he also observes that such devices had become more familiar in gothic and black metal decades later.

    Source details:

    1. Die harten Anfänge: METAL HAMMER in den Achtzigern · Metal Hammer · 2014-09-23
    2. Tom G. Warrior – recollections of Celtic Frost’s experiments on Into the Pandemonium · Blabbermouth.net / Blistering.com interview republication · Musician interview from around 2010
    3. Nuria Hochkirchen · Kreator: 40 Jahre Pleasure to Kill – the thrash/death boundary · Metal Hammer · 2026-04-01

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    043. Rock Hard – Über uns — Rock Hard

    Related passage: Before the Club Filled Up — Holger Stratmann and Uwe Lerch launched Dortmund’s Rock Hard as a fanzine in 1983

    Documented supporting details: According to the editorial team’s own historical account, the paper began in 1983 as a fanzine created by young fans Uwe Lerch and Holger Stratmann. The magazine claims that by 1987 it had become the first German fanzine distributed nationally. According to the venue’s own chronology, its first major concert was Nina Hagen’s performance on 14 December 1987. That account also gives 14 December 1987 for the Nina Hagen concert, so the event appears in two related institutional narratives rather than two independent pieces of primary evidence from 1987. The flexible audio insert and “Soundcheck” feature in 1985, the reception of major Metallica and Slayer albums in 1986, and the anniversary concert held in Dortmund in 1989 are identifiable elements of the new public infrastructure of the printed heavy-metal press.

    Source details:

    1. Rock Hard – Über uns · Rock Hard · Official editorial retrospective
    2. Die harten Anfänge: METAL HAMMER in den Achtzigern · Metal Hammer · 2014-09-23
    3. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history
    4. Bericht über 20 Jahre Longhorn · LKA Longhorn – archive · Later venue-history account (2004)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    044. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — In 1989, the Blue Blood seven-inch was something the band could take with them whenever they wanted to show someone how far they had come in rehearsal

    Documented supporting details: Krull sees the Blue Blood single as the first attempt to bring brutal and technical music together deliberately; they were still playing the songs onstage at that point, although the band had developed further since. [The musical difference between Blue Blood and the following album] Krull considers the material on the old “Blue Blood” single an early step in trying to bring together brutality and technical sophistication: he believes that with their later knowledge they would write the same songs differently and play them better. He speaks about the social importance of fanzines and grassroots organisation in the underground; he also mentions his writing for a regional southern German magazine called “Rockfabrik Live” and his own concert promotion. [00:09:38–00:15:02] In several recollections, the Rockfabrik near Ludwigsburg appears as a meeting place and part of the local concert scene around the early Atrocity.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Depth of Pain, 1992
    3. The documentary’s full authorial credits have not been established · Die Gottlosen Jahre – three-hour documentary on Atrocity’s career · Atrocity official discography, DVD (2012) · 2012 (DVD)

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    045. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — Krull organised his first underground festival there in October 1989

    Documented supporting details: An especially important personal and participant account concerns tour organisation: according to Krull, he staged his first underground festival at Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik in October 1989; he planned a second for June 1990, with Carcass as headliner. A plan for one concert grew into five events across three countries and ultimately a tour spanning nine countries in total.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    046. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — Blue Blood remained available by mail order

    Documented supporting details: In the contemporary 1992 Krull interview published by Depth of Pain, Blue Blood was still a single available by mail order; sales of more than four thousand were claimed by the musician himself, not verified by independent accounts. Krull considered the old songs open to rewriting and rerecording in the light of the instrumental experience the band had since gained. Early recollections in the later documentary Die Gottlosen Jahre provide a separate practical context: rehearsals in a cellar, then a cold farm building or garage, and cassette trading by post. The two temporal layers are not identical: the film is a retrospective, while Depth of Pain is a statement close to the period.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. The documentary’s full authorial credits have not been established · Die Gottlosen Jahre – three-hour documentary on Atrocity’s career · Atrocity official discography, DVD (2012) · 2012 (DVD)

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    047. Morrisound and Sunlight — two different death-metal soundscapes

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — Inside Morrisound in Tampa, Scott Burns worked on the details of a fast, dense death-metal sound

    Documented supporting details: Recording of Obituary’s Slowly We Rot began on the eight-track Otari machine at an earlier, smaller studio and was completed at the later Morrisound facility on 56th Street. The crucial turning point described by Skogsberg was Nihilist’s second demo in 1988, when the balance between guitar and drums later identified with the Sunlight sound began to emerge. According to Skogsberg, he had experimented with home recording as early as the 1970s and started recording bands with an eight-track tape machine in the 1980s. The museum chronology places the recording of Morbid Angel’s Altars of Madness at Morrisound in Tampa in December 1988 and gives 12 May 1989 as the release date, with Earache as the label. The tight guitar sound and sharply differentiated drum hits are an editorial interpretation of the sound; the details of the technical methods can be traced separately to statements by Burns.

    Source details:

    1. Tampa Bay Museum of Metal – Morbid Angel Altars of Madness · Tampa Bay Museum of Metal · Online museum chronology; year discussed: 1989
    2. Sam Retzer · Scott Burns: The Definition of Death Metal · Tape Op Magazine · Later interview with Scott Burns from 2026
    3. Death metal och kommunism – Tomas Skogsberg / Sunlight Studios · Proletären · Interview from around 2015

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    048. Nuclear Blast Records – About Us — Nuclear Blast Records

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — In Dortmund, Robert Kampf opened a new path for bands by founding Century Media in 1988

    Documented supporting details: According to the label’s own account, Markus Staiger founded Nuclear Blast Records in Germany in 1987, originally inspired by his interest in punk and hardcore. Century Media describes its own beginnings in Dortmund in 1988 as literally a “bedroom label”, a small home-based enterprise. According to Grewe, the material the band sent to record labels and magazines went unanswered for a long time, until Robert Kampf of the newly emerging Century Media expressed interest. For their next record he even raised the possibility of Scott Burns working with them in Germany; this was a plan in 1991, not a studio credit for the actual 1992 album. Lines 35–38. The label’s punk/hardcore beginnings in 1987 help explain the institutional record-company milieu of extreme metal in southern Germany.

    Source details:

    1. Nuclear Blast Records – About Us · Nuclear Blast Records · Official label history
    2. Century Media Records – The Label · Century Media Records · Official label history
    3. Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences · Voices from the Darkside · Later participant interview; website date uncertain
    4. Peardrop, 1990

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    049. Bericht über 20 Jahre Longhorn — LKA Longhorn – archive

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — At the same time, entirely different worlds of guitar and rhythm could be heard in Stuttgart

    Documented supporting details: Einstürzende Neubauten’s appearance at the Longhorn helps document the widening range of genres in Stuttgart’s concert scene: the institution’s sources on the 1980s show that avant-garde and industrial productions found a place alongside rock, punk and other alternative genres. The venue for the Stuttgart performance was the LKA Longhorn, with The Young Gods as the other band on the bill. Among the acts named for 1988 are soul musician Bobby Womack, industrial/new-wave group The Neon Judgement, Einstürzende Neubauten, Uriah Heep, Bo Diddley, country band Truck Stop and British punk group The Exploited. Müller recalls that in the early 1980s, members of the American military community living on installations around Stuttgart sought a meeting place of their own after encountering entry restrictions at other clubs.

    Source details:

    1. Bericht über 20 Jahre Longhorn · LKA Longhorn – archive · Later venue-history account (2004)
    2. Einstürzende Neubauten – chronology of the 1988 appearance at LKA Longhorn · From The Archives – concert chronology · Original event 1988-07-04

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    050. Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — On 12 June 1989, Kohl and Mikhail Gorbachev held talks in Bad Godesberg.

    Documented supporting details: Entries in the collection follow the opening of the Wall on 9 November, Hans Modrow’s first government statement as prime minister on the 17th and a resolution of the SED Central Committee on 3 December. The gallery also lists a report sent to the West German Permanent Representation on the internal situation in East Germany in June 1989, followed by a report dated 20 September 1989 concerning opposition groups.

    Source details:

    1. Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90 · Bundesarchiv · Events of 1989–1990; later official archival presentation

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    051. Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — By February 1990, preparations for an election were under way

    Documented supporting details: Documentary traces follow Sabine Bergmann-Pohl’s election as president of the Volkskammer on 6 April and Lothar de Maizière’s formation of a government on 12 April. The gallery marks the international dimension with the Germelmann memorandum of 21 February on preparations for the Two Plus Four Talks; domestic institutional decisions appear in the Volkskammer’s accession resolution of 23 August 1990, the letter from the parliamentary president on 25 August and the signing of the Unification Treaty by Schäuble and Krause on 31 August. The direct legal culmination of the article’s narrative is the opening of the Berlin Wall on 9 November 1989, the Unification Treaty of 31 August 1990 and the establishment of 3 October 1990 as the statutory Day of German Unity under that treaty.

    Source details:

    1. Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90 · Bundesarchiv · Events of 1989–1990; later official archival presentation
    2. Der Tag der deutschen Einheit – documents of 3 October 1990 · Bundesarchiv · 1990-10-03 (event), 2015 (presentation)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    052. Der Tag der deutschen Einheit – documents of 3 October 1990 — the year 1953

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — The new holiday replaced an older date

    Documented supporting details: The law of 4 August 1953 (BGBl. I 1953, p. 778) made 17 June the Day of German Unity and a public holiday. The East German protests of 17 June 1953 were linked to increases in work quotas and problems with supplies. Baden-Württemberg was established in 1952 by combining Baden, Württemberg-Baden and Württemberg-Hohenzollern. The population-history study examines the territory of the present-day state at different historical points.

    Source details:

    1. Der Tag der deutschen Einheit – documents of 3 October 1990 · Bundesarchiv · 1990-10-03 (event), 2015 (presentation)
    2. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    053. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — The tour planned around a Carcass concert did not yet exist when Krull discussed the invitation with the band

    Documented supporting details: A plan for one concert became five events in three countries, and ultimately a tour extending to nine countries in all. He describes the burdens of organising and performing as considerable but the outcome as successful; he mentions audiences averaging roughly five hundred and a concert in Czechoslovakia attended by two thousand people. He calls the agreement with Nuclear Blast a contemporary business and organisational question; when recalling the major shows on the tour with Carcass, he refers to an audience of approximately two thousand in Ostrava, Czechoslovakia. The period concerned cannot be assigned to a specific act of war or a particular day without separate evidence. [p. 8, early tour organisation and genre context] Krull remembers the Atrocity–Carcass tour as a personally positive experience, singling out the Paris concert.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Spikehead, 1991
    3. Blasphemous, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    054. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — The studio sessions for Hallucinations also had to be entered into the tour calendar

    Documented supporting details: He identifies several options that were rejected before the decision to record at Morrisound in the United States: Harris Johns’s schedule could not be reconciled with the already planned Carcass tour; Fleming Rasmussen would have been too expensive; the band had previously considered having Scott Burns mix the record, then decided to record the entire debut LP in Florida. He describes real personal contacts during the recording trip: Obituary lent them a drum kit; at the studio they met members of Incubus, Obituary, Deicide and Morbid Angel, with varying degrees of closeness. Hallucinations was made at Morrisound in Tampa with Scott Burns involved; he judged the recording demanding but successful, while emphasising the desire to move forward. Krull recalls independently making the Instigators demo, the Carcass tour and the approximately five-to-seven-day Florida recording of Hallucinations fitted between tours.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Holocaust, 1991 or 1992
    3. Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09
    4. Tampa Bay Museum of Metal – Morbid Angel Altars of Madness · Tampa Bay Museum of Metal · Online museum chronology; year discussed: 1989

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    055. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — The first album follows the tragic story of a girl from beginning to end

    Documented supporting details: Krull describes the selection of the Giger cover for Hallucinations: they wanted an abstract image, considered Dalí and Giger, eventually chose a particular Giger work, and Krull personally telephoned the artist and sent him an advance tape. He gives a detailed account of the anti-drug concept of Hallucinations: he began from his personal abstinence and opposition to drugs, regarded the subject as too large for one song, and therefore proposed a fictional story spanning an entire album to his bandmates. He links the album’s story of drug addiction to a young girl’s social and family circumstances, identifying the specific narrative stakes of the lyrics. The story concerns a girl raised in disadvantaged conditions who, after childhood trauma, becomes addicted and dies; Krull emphasises the social-critical dimension of the lyrics rather than blaming only the victim.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Blasphemous, 1991
    3. Peardrop, 1990

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    056. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — Following its release, Krull estimated sales during the first six weeks at around sixteen thousand copies

    Documented supporting details: His account of how the unusual music was received, and of the positive atmosphere on the tour with Sodom, is based on personal experience; audiences sometimes seemed confused, but he also connected that reaction to the music’s originality. According to Krull’s own description, the band does not play conventional death metal but seeks originality, complex ideas and brutality at the same time. The musicians had already composed and arranged instrumental parts meticulously on the demos because they wanted to preserve brutality despite the complexity.

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    057. Underground Empire, 1991

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — When the interviewer from Underground Empire placed Watchtower and Morbid Angel alongside Atrocity in the same sentence, Krull found the comparison useful

    Documented supporting details: Watchtower and Sieges Even appear as examples in the answer to the interviewer, but Matze adds that technical music of this kind is not an end in itself. He regards the interviewer’s “Watchtower meets Morbid Angel” comparison as acceptable journalistic wording while rejecting mere imitation of either band. The interview records personal recollections; the primary witness to the studio locations and responsibilities is the booklet of the 1992 album. (Underground Empire, p. 18.) According to Krull, Atrocity had developed considerably as artists during the two years between Hallucinations and Todessehnsucht. He cites an interest in listening to classical music as one possible influence on the creative mixture, but adds that the music resulting from it is the product of the band members’ own decisions. Underground Empire, issue 5 (source identifier ATR-TOD-01-006).

    Source details:

    1. Underground Empire, 1991
    2. Peardrop, 1990
    3. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    058. Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences

    Related passage: October at the Rockfabrik — German bands followed several diverging routes between the studio and distribution

    Documented supporting details: Grewe links the spring 1990 tour with Autopsy and Pestilence to the geographical limits of Century Media’s distribution network at the time: according to him, this was why they mostly played shows in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, while another band replaced them at dates in Belgium and the Netherlands. The article names Scott Burns and Randy Burns as two different professionals in connection with separate jobs (mixing The Eternal Fall EP / mixing the album Cursed). According to the edited historical narrative, Cees Wessels founded Roadrunner in the Netherlands in 1980, initially licensing a variety of musical styles; its metal profile grew stronger in the mid-1980s, a New York office was established, and after the breakthrough of King Diamond’s *Abigail* in 1987, death metal in the late 1980s became particularly important.

    Source details:

    1. Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences · Voices from the Darkside · Later participant interview; website date uncertain
    2. Metal Hammer, 2017
    3. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    059. Operation “Ace Guard” – Golfkrieg und deutsche Proteste 1991

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — On 2 August 1990, Iraq invaded Kuwait.

    Documented supporting details: UN Security Council Resolution 660 demanded Iraq’s immediate withdrawal; the US troop deployment under Operation “Desert Shield” was intended to protect allies present in the region. According to the Bundesarchiv, the German units returned in March 1991; service on allied territory in Turkey did not turn into direct combat, and the anticipated armed clashes did not occur. This is an additional, independent fanzine testimony to the same personal and state-service context discussed more fully in the Depth of Pain interview. [p. 8, Germany and the war] Asked about the fall of the Berlin Wall, Alex offers a brief, bitter comment on the transition in the former East German territories: after freedom had been won, material concerns came to the fore.

    Source details:

    1. Operation “Ace Guard” – Golfkrieg und deutsche Proteste 1991 · Bundesarchiv · 1991 (event; later archival presentation)
    2. Spikehead, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    060. Dejan Djokić — after the Yugoslav elections of 1990, the year 1991

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Earlier layers of the South Slav state’s history led back to the rearrangements between 1912 and 1921, its partition in 1941 and the reorganisation that followed the war

    Documented supporting details: After the Yugoslav elections of 1990, the declarations of independence by Slovenia and Croatia in June 1991, followed by the war in Croatia, led to waves of violence of different magnitudes. The study presents the seizure of Slovenian border crossings in June 1991, clashes with the Yugoslav People’s Army, the war in Croatia in 1991–1992 and the fighting that spread through Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1992 as a connected process. Existing networks of family and acquaintances in Germany, established through Yugoslav labour migration during the 1960s and 1970s, explicitly helped people fleeing the conflict to find routes and make their first contacts. Yugoslavia took shape as a state between 1912 and 1921 amid conflicts, diplomatic negotiations and domestic political changes; in 1941 it was partitioned under German, Italian and allied occupation, then reunited after the Second World War.

    Source details:

    1. Dejan Djokić · Über Grenzen und Gedenken – the breakup of Yugoslavia · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2021-11-29; period discussed: 1991–1992
    2. Jochen Oltmer · “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2023-01-20; period discussed: 1991–1992
    3. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    061. The Sodom–Atrocity tour — concert list for 1991

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Atrocity’s concert list records sixteen shows with Sodom between 19 January and 6 February 1991.

    Documented supporting details: The site lists sixteen shows marked as performances with Sodom between 19 January and 6 February: Osnabrück, Bremen, Hamburg, Berlin, Nuremberg, Frankfurt, Ludwigshafen, Winterthur, Vienna, Munich, Stuttgart–Longhorn, Kaufbeuren, Jena, Kassel, Lichtenfels and Oberhausen. The spring list includes Aue and Poland’s Metal Mania/Bytom area; June brings Ludwigshafen–Pforzheim; July Bamberg (Morbid Angel, Dismember); August venues in eastern Germany; September shared dates with Sinister in the Netherlands and Belgium; and finally Dortmund and Meer. In his recollection, members of Sinister heard the advance recording during a joint tour and responded enthusiastically; this gave rise to the opportunity for him and Matze Röderer to produce Sinister’s debut album, Cross the Styx.

    Source details:

    1. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive
    2. Depth of Pain, 1992
    3. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history
    4. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    062. Spikehead, 1991

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Speaking to Spikehead, Krull still talked enthusiastically about Tampa and Scott Burns

    Documented supporting details: This is an additional, independent fanzine testimony to the same personal and state-service context explored more fully in the Depth of Pain interview. [p. 8, Germany and the war] Asked about the fall of the Berlin Wall, Alex offers a brief, bitter assessment of the transition in the former East German territories: after freedom was won, material concerns came to the fore. He also identifies civilian-service obligations undertaken by him and some bandmates as a concrete source of difficulties for touring.

    Source details:

    1. Spikehead, 1991

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    063. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Röderer was studying, while Krull was carrying out civilian service

    Documented supporting details: They were not unhappy with the earlier, successful American Morrisound/Scott Burns recordings for Hallucinations; they chose a different direction because they felt that the sound of contemporary death-metal albums often resembled one another, and they wanted to develop a sound of their own. He assigns an important role to hard work in rehearsal and debate among different individual conceptions: five people with five different opinions had to reach shared decisions. Matze and Richard’s role in initiating musical ideas; reconciling five different views within the band; a routine based on three rehearsals per week alongside work, study and civilian service; and, according to Krull, disputed label accounting inherited from the Hallucinations era. [Pre-production, studio, deliberate change of direction] According to Krull, the band had already tried out a studio in Germany where they intended to record the next album.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. Aberration, 1993
    3. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    064. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — He recalled two different audience figures for concerts in Poland: in Depth of Pain he spoke of about six thousand at a Metal Mania appearance, while in Aberration he mentioned more than eight thousand…

    Documented supporting details: He mentions hospital work and work with people with disabilities or older people as possible forms of civilian service; in their own circumstances he speaks of several more months of service and the hope of leave in return. He recalls their earlier European tour with Carcass and the tour with Sodom in January 1991; he also mentions a Dutch tour, an appearance at Poland’s Metal Mania festival before an audience of around six thousand according to his account, and concerts shared with Master, Pungent Stench, Morbid Angel and Napalm Death. In another, earlier Depth of Pain interview he gave nearly six thousand for the same or a similar Polish event.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    065. Atheist interview – 1991 (Disposable Underground #3)

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Steve Flynn was already discussing Atheist’s Unquestionable Presence in 1991

    Documented supporting details: In 1991, Flynn said they had not wanted to depart from Morrisound for the recording of Unquestionable Presence: the studio and Scott Burns offered familiar and predictable sound quality following the preceding album. Within this snapshot of the genre in 1991, the spread of more complex song structures and progressive harmonies can be presented alongside the specific 1991 interview with Steve Flynn about Unquestionable Presence, while retaining its status as a separate type of evidence. Flynn’s account of the creative process is particularly important: according to him, a song’s basic form and its guitar parts could take shape comparatively quickly, in two or three weeks, but revisions to the drum arrangements frequently involved a month or more. The label identifies Human (1991) as Death’s fourth studio album and stresses its intricate, progressive arrangements and more introspective lyrical themes.

    Source details:

    1. Atheist interview – 1991 (interview with Steve Flynn) · Disposable Underground, issue 3 (1991) · Online archiving of the original 1991 interview: 19 September 2022.
    2. Human (1991) – Death, progressive death metal · Relapse Records · Later label overview; year discussed: 1991

    Source-critical limits: The 1991 Steve Flynn interview presents the musician’s own account of the band’s working methods, not an independent studio log. The later Relapse account of Death’s Human is separate record-label commentary and does not establish any direct creative connection between the two bands.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    066. Paradise Lost – Gothic (1991), historical label account

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Formed in 1988, Paradise Lost followed 1990’s Lost Paradise by recording Gothic at Academy Studios in late 1990 and early 1991

    Documented supporting details: According to Peaceville’s published material on the early period, My Dying Bride’s 1990 demo Towards the Sinister, the 1991 single material God Is Alone and their 1992 debut album As the Flower Withers were important stages in the gradual development of a heavy, slower and more ceremonial British death/doom musical idiom. According to the interviewer’s parenthetical identification, Paradise Lost played Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik on 14 April 1991. Peaceville presents Paradise Lost’s beginnings in 1988 and the dark, death-metal-derived sound of 1990’s Lost Paradise, with slower tempos and an atmosphere of melodic guitars, as an important early phase in the transformation of the British underground. It dates work on Gothic to late 1990 and early 1991 at Academy Studios in Yorkshire and presents the album’s release in 1991 as a defining moment in the emergence of gothic doom metal.

    Source details:

    1. Paradise Lost – Gothic (1991), historical label account · Peaceville Records · Later official band/album account
    2. My Dying Bride – early Peaceville years and As the Flower Withers · Peaceville Records · Label history of the band
    3. Greg Mackintosh: Paradise Lost – Live in Ludwigsburg, 1991 · rockmetal.pl · Later musician interview from 2021
    4. Geschichte der Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Official history of the venue

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    067. Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — For Morgoth’s album Cursed, Sebastian Swart cited the dark gothic rock of Fields of the Nephilim as a musical reference

    Documented supporting details: The article names Scott Burns and Randy Burns as two separate professionals in connection with different projects (mixing The Eternal Fall EP / mixing the album Cursed). More important still is the personal statement on musical origins: the band studied the dark gothic rock they were listening to at the time, especially the atmosphere of Fields of the Nephilim and the means used to convey it, and this played a part in Cursed’s darker ambience. It associates the mixing of the four recordings in 1991 with work by Falk Gruber and Alex Krull, and attributes the remastering in 2021 to Alex Krull. They were not dissatisfied with the earlier, successful American Morrisound/Scott Burns recordings for Hallucinations; they chose a different direction because they felt contemporary death-metal albums often sounded alike and wanted to create a sound of their own.

    Source details:

    1. Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences · Voices from the Darkside · Later participant interview; website date uncertain
    2. Aberration, 1993
    3. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    068. Author unidentified

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — In September 1991, four tracks were placed on the early tape with which Atrocity approached Roadrunner

    Documented supporting details: According to Rock Hard, the original demo material from 1991 contains early recordings of four compositions: “Sky Turned Red”, “Unspoken Names”, “Defiance” and “A Prison Called Earth”. Krull says, for example, that the album version of Sky Turned Red sounds somewhat different from the demo; he regards this as part of the value of those rawer early versions. The relevant portion of the Atrocity interview appears on pages 18–19 of Rock Hard. (Rock Hard, p. 18.) The most important statement, based on Alex Krull’s recollection, is that in September 1991 they recorded a promotional tape for Roadrunner Records. The four recordings were mixed in 1991 by Falk Gruber and Alex Krull together; the 2021 remastering is attributed to Alex Krull.

    Source details:

    1. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    2. Alexandra Michels · ATROCITY – “Unspoken Names (Demo 1991)”: overview of the original 1991 advance recordings · Rock Hard – Alexandra Michels · 2021-11-25
    3. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    069. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Speaking to Depth of Pain, Krull described plans to begin recording in January and an album expected in April

    Documented supporting details: He names Psychotic Waltz, Primus, Mozart and Wagner, as well as musical ideas from the classical tradition. He mentions several traditional heavy-metal bands among his favourites, including Raven, Judas Priest and Iron Maiden, and talks about listening to electronic and dance-music records alongside Laibach, Death and Entombed. Krull also discusses questions of genre identity and musical references. He finds “death metal” inadequate as a description on its own: when discussing their music, he invokes classical ideas, progressive and technical directions, and points of reference such as Nasty Savage and Watchtower. He promises greater musical variety, extreme shifts in tempo, blast beats and slow passages.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    070. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — During the same period, Krull also mentioned Nocturnus’s The Key, Mike Browning’s early work with Morbid Angel and the music of Type O Negative

    Documented supporting details: His favourites include Nocturnus and The Key, early Morbid Angel and Mike Browning, Psychotic Waltz and Type O Negative; he has reservations about the lyrics of the last of these bands. He regards the fact that formerly underground artists such as Morbid Angel, Carcass, Massacre, Master and Immolation were making full-length albums as both a natural step forward and a transformation of the older self-organised scene. In the Corpus Christi side project, he describes his role as drummer and singer.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. Holocaust, 1991 or 1992

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    071. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — The Longhorn’s list places Sonic Youth and Nirvana on the same bill on 29 August 1991

    Documented supporting details: He mentions several traditional heavy-metal bands among his favourites, including Raven, Judas Priest and Iron Maiden, and talks about listening to electronic and dance-music records alongside Laibach, Death and Entombed. Psychotic Waltz, Primus, Mozart and Wagner also appear by name, as do ideas from classical music. The source names the Sonic Youth–Nirvana concert of 29 August 1991; the suggestion that it “did not excite everyone” is a retrospective impression on the page, not an objective measure of audience reaction. Performances by Napalm Death (9 October 1990), Exodus (30 October 1990), Kreator (10 December 1990), and in 1991 by Dark Angel (2 April), Sepultura (6 June), Bad Brains (26 June) and Bad Religion (27 June) demonstrate the range of heavy-music scenes using the region’s concert infrastructure (PDF p. 116).

    Source details:

    1. Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history
    2. POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004 · LKA Longhorn, its own application documentation · Archival compilation from 2006, original concert list covering 1987–2004
    3. Aberration, 1993
    4. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    5. Metal Hammer, 2017

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    072. Nuclear Blast and Roadrunner — Krull’s statement and the official chronology

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Blue Blood and Hallucinations had still appeared on Nuclear Blast

    Documented supporting details: In contemporary interviews in Aberration and Nagual, Krull presents his dissatisfaction with the Nuclear Blast contract and the dispute over accounting as his own position. His estimate of thirty to forty thousand copies sold of Hallucinations is a musician’s estimate, not verified accounting data. He cites broader distribution and the possibility of overseas tours as reasons to favour Roadrunner; the detailed legal conditions of the multi-album agreement mentioned are not documented by the interview alone. The band’s official biography supports the chronology of the switch, but does not independently settle the financial dispute.

    Source details:

    1. Aberration, 1993
    2. Nagual, 1993
    3. ATROCITY – Bio (official band biography) · Atrocity – official website · Original online publication date not supplied
    4. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    073. Metal Hammer, 2017

    Related passage: A Year Between Two Albums — Roadrunner built an international catalogue through which several strands of heavy metal reached listeners across national borders

    Documented supporting details: According to Alex Krull’s retrospective account, Todessehnsucht was recorded in Germany, produced by the band itself, and financed for the studio work by Roadrunner Records. The original release’s cover and booklet contain the authorship and technical credits. The cover of the original Roadrunner release bears the name “ATROCITY”. This stage in the growth of the label and its roster matters to a wider musical and industry understanding of the 1992 Atrocity–Roadrunner agreement, but the article does NOT assert any separate Atrocity-specific contractual motive or personal Conner–Krull connection. They were not dissatisfied with the earlier, successful American Morrisound/Scott Burns recordings for Hallucinations; they chose another direction because they felt contemporary death-metal albums often sounded similar and wanted to develop their own sound.

    Source details:

    1. Metal Hammer, 2017
    2. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Source-critical limits: Alex Krull’s retrospective account is first-hand creative testimony about the recording location and production arrangements; on its own, it does not establish the label’s internal decision-making, the exact contractual terms or a separate personal Conner–Krull connection.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    074. Werner Brachat-Schwarz — Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — Baden-Württemberg passed the ten-million population threshold in 1992

    Documented supporting details: According to the text, foreign citizens accounted for about 70 per cent of net immigration in 1992, while the share of foreign citizens reached 12.4 per cent by the end of that year, compared with 11.5 per cent at the end of 1991 (PDF p. 3). The study reports two migration figures that must be kept distinct: net international migration into the state amounted to almost 470,000 people from 1989 to 1992, while the net gain from the new eastern German states was about 90,000 from 1990 to 1992 (PDF p. 6, printed p. 8). The authors stress that following particularly heavy immigration from 1989 to 1991, the positive migration balance fell to approximately 125,000 in 1992; a net inflow of migrants nevertheless remained the decisive factor in population growth.

    Source details:

    1. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)
    2. Wirtschafts- und Sozialentwicklung in Baden-Württemberg 1993 – figures for 1992 · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg · Statistical publication from around 1994 (figures for 1992)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    075. Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The Bundesbank’s year-end report recorded a slowdown in the West German economy

    Documented supporting details: According to the West German labour-market data, the seasonally adjusted number of registered unemployed people rose by approximately 100,000 between late August and late November 1992 to around 1.95 million (p. 7). West German real GDP fell by 0.5 per cent in the third quarter of 1992 compared with the previous quarter, adjusted for seasonal and working-day effects (pp. 5 and 31; confirmed by the GDP table on p. 34). The economic slowdown had become evident in increased short-time working at the end of 1991; the annual average number of workers on reduced hours in 1992 more than doubled compared with the preceding year. The particularly severe recession figures for 1993 concern separate, later dates.

    Source details:

    1. Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany · Deutsche Bundesbank · 1992-12 (original publication)
    2. Wirtschafts- und Sozialentwicklung in Baden-Württemberg 1993 – figures for 1992 · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg · Statistical publication from around 1994 (figures for 1992)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    076. Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — After reunification, the eastern states faced even more severe labour-market losses

    Documented supporting details: According to the labour-market table on page 38, the eastern states had approximately 1.0865 million registered unemployed people in November 1992, alongside 235,600 workers on short-time arrangements; the report does not treat these groups as the same category. The table for the West German labour market on page 32 gives seasonally adjusted registered unemployment of about 1.947 million in November 1992 and around 478,000 people on short-time work; the text rounds these values to 1.95 million and 480,000 respectively.

    Source details:

    1. Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany · Deutsche Bundesbank · 1992-12 (original publication)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    077. Maastricht Treaty – the founding treaty of the later EU — Maastricht in 1992

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The Treaty on European Union was signed at Maastricht on 7 February 1992.

    Documented supporting details: The Maastricht Treaty was signed on 7 February 1992, but according to the cited site it entered into force only on 1 November 1993. The official account highlights preparations for European economic and monetary union, the creation of formal Union citizenship, elements of common foreign policy and cooperation on internal affairs, and opportunities for Parliament to participate in joint decision-making. The report separately notes the exit of the Italian lira and British pound from the EMS exchange-rate mechanism and devaluations of the Spanish peseta and Portuguese escudo; these must not be described as one general, uniform European financial “collapse”. In its discussion of the 1992 crisis in the European Monetary System (pp. 8–10), the report traces the exchange-rate adjustments and interventions of the autumn.

    Source details:

    1. Maastricht Treaty – founding treaty of the later EU · European Union – official founding agreements · 1992-02-07 (signed), 1993-11-01 (entered into force)
    2. Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany · Deutsche Bundesbank · 1992-12 (original publication)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    078. Dejan Djokić — Über Grenzen und Gedenken – the breakup of Yugoslavia

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — Meanwhile, in southeastern Europe, war also broke out in Bosnia and Herzegovina following the Slovenian and Croatian conflicts of 1991

    Documented supporting details: According to the 2023 study, by summer 1992 about 2.2 million people — approximately half the population of Bosnia and Herzegovina at the time — had been forced to leave their homes. The study presents the seizure of Slovenian border crossings in June 1991, clashes with the Yugoslav People’s Army, the Croatian war of 1991–1992 and the fighting that engulfed Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1992 as parts of a connected process. “Duldung” was not a full residence permit but a temporary suspension of deportation. Refugees from the war in southeastern Europe, internal migration after German reunification, resettlers arriving from the former Soviet area and rules for distributing new arrivals all shaped the region together.

    Source details:

    1. Dejan Djokić · Über Grenzen und Gedenken – the breakup of Yugoslavia · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2021-11-29; period discussed: 1991–1992
    2. Jochen Oltmer · “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2023-01-20; period discussed: 1991–1992
    3. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    079. Jochen Oltmer — “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — During the war years, Baden-Württemberg became an important destination for people seeking refuge

    Documented supporting details: According to the article, the number of asylum applications in Germany was approximately 190,000 in 1990, almost 260,000 in 1991 and around 440,000 in 1992. Later state-level figures for 1995 list 47,943 Bosnian war refugees in Baden-Württemberg, rising to 60,000 in 1996, who had not submitted applications for asylum. Likewise, the total German admission figure of 350,000 refers to a retrospective count for the entire Bosnian war, not the number of refugees present simultaneously in 1992.

    Source details:

    1. Jochen Oltmer · “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2023-01-20; period discussed: 1991–1992
    2. Thomas Prenzel · Vor 30 Jahren: Die rassistisch motivierten Ausschreitungen von Rostock-Lichtenhagen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2022-08-17; events of August 1992

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    080. Thomas Prenzel — Vor 30 Jahren: Die rassistisch motivierten Ausschreitungen von Rostock-Lichtenhagen

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — On 22 August, a racist attack began in Rostock-Lichtenhagen against an asylum seekers’ reception centre and people living in the adjacent building

    Documented supporting details: On 24 August, the asylum seekers’ reception centre was evacuated, but the building housing Vietnamese residents became the new main target. From a crowd of several thousand gathering in Rostock on 22 August 1992, attackers threw stones and incendiary devices at the reception centre and nearby accommodation for Vietnamese contract workers.

    Source details:

    1. Thomas Prenzel · Vor 30 Jahren: Die rassistisch motivierten Ausschreitungen von Rostock-Lichtenhagen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2022-08-17; events of August 1992
    2. Jochen Oltmer · “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2023-01-20; period discussed: 1991–1992

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    081. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016 — the new project described as costing 46 million German marks

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — Trains had been running between the towns of Württemberg since 1846

    Documented supporting details: The Bahn-Passage Ludwigsburg, a commercial and services centre described as costing 46 million German marks and containing approximately 10,000 m² of lettable floor space, was inaugurated on 19 November 1992 (printed pp. 160–161, PDF pp. 144–145). According to printed page 133, in November 1846 a special theatre train was already helping people from Ludwigsburg attend performances in Stuttgart: a concrete connection between transport and cultural life. The study examines the territory of present-day Baden-Württemberg through historical cross-sections. The state was formed in 1952 by merging Baden, Württemberg-Baden and Württemberg-Hohenzollern. Together, the places and dates show that by 1990 early Atrocity was in fact operating within an international underground touring network; the tour list does not describe the detailed course of individual shared performances.

    Source details:

    1. Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016
    2. Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – the population history of Baden-Württemberg · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)
    3. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive
    4. EB/METRONOM, 1992

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    082. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — While shops were taking shape around the station, Stuttgart’s state administration, industry and cultural institutions remained close to one another

    Documented supporting details: The date belongs to the local cultural institutions of the late 1980s and is not the year the building was constructed. The second installation, located in the protected Strümpfelbachtal area near Nonnenmühle, played a role in Althütte’s water supply from 1937, with a capacity of 63 litres per minute. The actual date of the municipal merger was 1 July 1971, in agreement with municipal history item 06-010. These events should appear in any later depiction of local history with their actual historical participants, without inventing family relationships or a personal influence on Atrocity. After 1945, Stuttgart’s economy, new municipal administration and public institutions were rebuilt; from 1952 it was the capital of Baden-Württemberg. In 1956, the new town hall, Liederhalle and television tower opened, while modernisation also led to the demolition of a number of older historical buildings.

    Source details:

    1. Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21
    2. Stuttgart-Mitte – history of the city centre · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · Historical overview of the district
    3. Die Gemeinde Althütte – municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · Municipal historical overview
    4. Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks and local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · Museum founded in 1988 and earlier local historical data
    5. BKZ – article author unidentified · Holpriger Start in eine gemeinsame Zukunft – administrative reform in Fautspach/Sechselberg · Backnanger Kreiszeitung (BKZ) · 2021 (retrospective on events of 1971–1972)
    6. Das S-Bahn Netz im Stuttgarter Raum / frühere industrielle Verkehrsachsen · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart – historical statistics · Statistical historical study published in 2009
    7. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, American CD and booklet.

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    083. POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The 1992 concert season in Stuttgart unfolds through widely differing musical evenings in a venue calendar published later

    Documented supporting details: Among the exact concert dates in the 1992 list around the album’s original release year are Overkill on 9 February; Prong on 16 March; Carcass with the designation “Gods of Grind” on 29 March; Paradise Lost on 16 April; Obituary on 11 June; Testament on 21 September; Sodom on 25 October; and Helmet on 13 December.

    Source details:

    1. POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004 · LKA Longhorn, its own application documentation · Archival compilation from 2006, original concert list covering 1987–2004
    2. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive
    3. EB/METRONOM, 1992
    4. Atrocity – Concert Archives: concerts between 1990 and 1992 · Concert Archives – community event archive · 1990–1992 (historical concert years)

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    084. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The city’s musical life was changing in other buildings too

    Documented supporting details: According to the source, Martha Schuster served as organist from 1978 to 1991 and Manfred Schreier as cantor from 1978 to 1994; Stuttgart’s liturgical and concert-music tradition thus remained institutionally active during the period from 1985 to 1992. The city took over the institution in 1976. A turning point in 1992 was the acquisition of central offices, teaching rooms and concert halls in the Rotebühlzentrum, while teaching continued to become more decentralised across the districts. From its foundation, the school had served two distinct social and musical needs: the professional branch prepared musicians for careers, while amateurs of different ages could learn instruments and singing in the “Dilettantenschule”. The community of canons at Beutelsbach moved to Stuttgart around 1321, and the earliest secure evidence for the Stiftskirche organ dates from 1381.

    Source details:

    1. Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview
    2. Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page
    3. Musik der Jahrhunderte – history (1978–1992) · Musik der Jahrhunderte Stuttgart · Official institutional history
    4. Stuttgart bei Nacht – historical club scene from the 1970s to the 1990s · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · Official city study from 2024, database covering 2023 and earlier

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not demonstrate a direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    085. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — Falk Gruber worked with Atrocity on the recording at Mainstreet Studio

    Documented supporting details: An everyday benefit of choosing a nearby studio was that the band members could sometimes go home to sleep rather than having to stay on a long, isolated overseas recording trip. The credits printed in the booklet of the 1992 CD read: `Produced by Atrocity`; `Recorded at Mainstreet Studio, Fautspach`; `Engineered by Falk Gruber and Atrocity`; `Mixed at Daylight Studios, Stuttgart`; `Mixed by Alex Krull`; `Engineered by Florian Brugger`; `Mastered at Bauer Studios, Ludwigsburg`; `Mastered by Gerd Puchelt & Alex Krull`; `Keyboards and Sequencer by Alex Krull`. On page 19 he separately names the two guitarists, Matze and Richard, as the principal initiators of musical ideas, while stressing that the whole band contributes suggestions and that Krull himself also tried to bring in musical parts.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Aberration, 1993
    3. Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    086. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The tapes went next to Daylight in Stuttgart

    Documented supporting details: The mastering at Bauer Studios is credited to Gerd Puchelt and Alexander Krull. The booklet of the 1992 CD gives the following credits: `Produced by Atrocity`; `Recorded at Mainstreet Studio, Fautspach`; `Engineered by Falk Gruber and Atrocity`; `Mixed at Daylight Studios, Stuttgart`; `Mixed by Alex Krull`; `Engineered by Florian Brugger`; `Mastered at Bauer Studios, Ludwigsburg`; `Mastered by Gerd Puchelt & Alex Krull`; `Keyboards and Sequencer by Alex Krull`. Alexander Krull mixed the recording at Daylight Studios, with Florian Brugger responsible for engineering. According to his account, they spent around four weeks recording the album at the studio used for the promotional cassette, then mixed the material for another two weeks at a different location in Stuttgart.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Aberration, 1993
    3. Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09
    4. ATROCITY – Todessehnsucht: original studio work and credits in the label’s account · Massacre Records – label news page, 07/2020 · 2020-07 (website month)

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    087. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The two guitars were played by Röderer and Scharf

    Documented supporting details: The music for the album’s title track is credited to Mathias Röderer, with lyrics by Krull; the music for `Unspoken Names` is credited to Röderer and Oliver Klasen, with lyrics by Krull; the music for `Defiance` to Röderer and Scharf, with lyrics by Krull. The music-writing line for `Godless Years` names Scharf, Klasen, Schwarz and Röderer; the collective contribution to composition must be stressed. On page 19 he separately names the two guitarists, Matze and Richard, as the principal initiators of musical ideas, while emphasising that everyone contributes suggestions and Krull himself also tried to provide musical parts. The original CD booklet carries two credit lines with different purposes: the overall track-rights/authorship statement on page 2 does not erase the separate arrangement and lyric credits on page 7; it does not, in itself, allow a final conclusion about legal authorship.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    4. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.
    5. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: Contemporary interview material is a statement reported by a participant or journalist: personal recollections, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification in record-label or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    088. Four guest vocalists in the credits of the original 1992 CD

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The booklet lists four vocal registers alongside the lead voice: Robert Russ as countertenor, Stefan as tenor, Johannes as baritone and Florian Lothe as bass

    Documented supporting details: On the second booklet image of the 1992 Roadrunner CD, the guest CROONERS are credited in four vocal registers: Robert Russ as countertenor, Stefan as tenor, Johannes as baritone and Florian Lothe as bass. The surnames of Stefan and Johannes cannot be established with complete confidence from the surviving low-resolution line. These four voices are four vocal contributors, not a full symphony orchestra. The larger arrangement envisaged in the 2007 retrospective, and the financial obstacle that prevented it, should be treated as a participant’s recollection, not as a production fact documented by the booklet.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Metal Mind Productions, 2007. MASS CD 1072 DG, booklet retrospective.

    Source-critical limits: The inscriptions, track listings and credits on the original physical release are primary documents; they do not by themselves establish the motives behind recording decisions, and indistinct small print must not be completed through guesswork.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    089. Original band, recording and image credits on the 1992 CD

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — Anyone turning the page from the five musician portraits encountered a different order of responsibilities

    Documented supporting details: Page 2 of the CD booklet documents the five members and the technical staff working at the three locations on separate lines: Falk Gruber appears with the recording in Fautspach, Florian Brugger with the mix in Stuttgart and Gerd Puchelt with mastering in Ludwigsburg. The original credits name Atrocity as producer, and also credit Krull with keyboards and sequencer. On pages 4–7, the individual Music/Lyrics/Arranged lines distinguish composition from arrangements. Gianna Possehl is credited for the cover and rose photographs, Christian Bruch for the band photographs. The collective producer credit does not cancel the individual division of labour.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 4.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    4. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    5. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.
    6. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.

    Source-critical limits: The inscriptions, track listings and credits on the original physical release are primary documents; they do not by themselves establish the motives behind recording decisions, and indistinct small print must not be completed through guesswork.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    090. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — Listeners to Hallucinations could follow the thread of a single story

    Documented supporting details: In a 1992 statement printed by Depth of Pain, Krull distinguishes the continuous fictional story of drug use on Hallucinations from the separate and more poetic lyrics of the second album. Booklet pages 5–7 of the original 1992 CD print the lyrics and the Music/Lyrics/Arranged credits for the individual songs. The return of the title theme and its reprise can also be traced in the printed track listing. The thematic reading is anchored to the actual lyric passages and does not make Todessehnsucht a single-narrative concept album in the way Hallucinations was.

    Source details:

    1. Depth of Pain, 1992
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    4. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    5. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.

    Source-critical limits: A contemporary interview is a participant’s or journalist’s account. Personal memories, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification from a label’s records or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    091. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 5. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In the opening, Krull set the image of a leaf separating from its branch to Röderer’s music

    Documented supporting details: The music for the album’s title track is credited to Mathias Röderer, and its lyrics to Krull; Unspoken Names credits Röderer and Oliver Klasen for music and Krull for lyrics; Defiance credits Röderer and Scharf for music and Krull for lyrics. The composers line for Godless Years lists Scharf, Klasen, Schwarz and Röderer: the collective contribution to composition should be explicitly recognised.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    093. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 5. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — When Godless Years begins, images of mortality give way to images of humanity’s own power

    Documented supporting details: The title track credits Mathias Röderer for music and Krull for words; Unspoken Names credits Röderer and Oliver Klasen for music and Krull for words; Defiance credits Röderer and Scharf for music and Krull for words. The composers line for Godless Years names Scharf, Klasen, Schwarz and Röderer, and the shared compositional contribution must be stressed. This does not replace the album’s and tracks’ authorship fields. The original CD booklet contains the lyrics of Todessehnsucht, Godless Years, Unspoken Names and Defiance, with separate Music, Lyrics and Arranged credits for each.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    095. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 5. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — On the demo, Unspoken Names had to provide a title for all four tracks; on the finished album, it comes third and has time to linger over the unspeakable

    Documented supporting details: The title track credits Mathias Röderer for music and Krull for lyrics; Unspoken Names credits Röderer and Oliver Klasen for music and Krull for lyrics; Defiance credits Röderer and Scharf for music and Krull for lyrics. Godless Years names Scharf, Klasen, Schwarz and Röderer in its composition line; the collective role in writing must be emphasised. Authorship and technical information appear on the original release’s cover and in the booklet. The name ATROCITY appears on the cover of the original Roadrunner edition.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    2. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    3. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    097. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 5. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In Defiance, violence tests and attempts to break the will; the booklet credits Röderer and Scharf with the music

    Documented supporting details: Page 5 of the original CD booklet credits Mathias Röderer and Richard Scharf with the music for Defiance, and Alex Krull with the lyrics. On page 6, Triumph at Dawn likewise credits Röderer and Scharf for music and Krull for lyrics. Separate Lead credits identify particular instrumental lead parts, not new lists of complete songwriters. The differing images of violence and resistance in the two lyrics are readings of printed texts, not documented statements by the writers about specific contemporary political events.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    3. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    099. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 6. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — During the ninety seconds of Introduction, the album’s sound changes direction before Sky Turned Red begins

    Documented supporting details: The music for Triumph at Dawn and Sky Turned Red is credited to Röderer and Scharf, their lyrics to Krull. A statement about the shared tour, the album and the two producers’ respective roles comes from a speaker’s recollections in 2022, not an independent contemporary witness. Beside several song lyrics, the image shows the partial credits “Lead: Röderer” and “Lead: Scharf”. These refer to particular instrumental or solo parts; they do not change the band’s five-piece line-up. In the original CD booklet, Triumph at Dawn, Introduction, Sky Turned Red and Necropolis appear in separate lyric and performer-credit blocks. Krull also discusses a connection drawn between Sky Turned Red and Wagner, and differences in responses to the German-language title and lyrics. The speaker is Alex Krull; a suggestion in the interviewer’s question must not automatically be treated as Krull’s personal recollection.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.
    3. Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09
    4. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    101. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 6. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — Necropolis moves from images of human destruction towards the cemetery

    Documented supporting details: On page 6 of the 1992 CD booklet, Richard Scharf and Mathias Röderer appear in the music credit for Necropolis, and Alex Krull in the lyrics credit. Page 7 credits Röderer with the music for A Prison Called Earth, Krull with the words, and Atrocity with the arrangement. Images of destruction and confinement in the two songs can be interpreted from the preserved lyrics. The instrumental tempo changes, differences between the demo and album mixes, and the relative prominence of guest voices are separate critical judgments based on listening; the printed credits do not establish those points.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.
    3. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    103. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 4. booklet image.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — The opening theme by Röderer returns in the tenth piece

    Documented supporting details: The cover version of Death’s Archangel is discussed as an idea agreed with Chuck Schuldiner, using partly rewritten lyrics; the printed original album credits record the authorship roles separately. On its own song page, Archangel is credited “Music: Schuldiner”, “Lyrics: Krull”, “Arranged by Atrocity”, whereas the summary line on page 2 reads “Archangel by Chuck Schuldiner”. Regarding the Death cover recorded in 1992, Krull describes Archangel as an older composition by Chuck, dating from about 1985, that Schuldiner reportedly had not wanted to release until then.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 4.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.
    3. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.
    4. Orpheus Spiliotopoulos (Eleni also asks questions) · Alex Krull – interview from the Atlantis period · Metal Temple · 2004-06-13
    5. Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    105. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — Gianna Possehl’s artwork placed dark, dried roses on the cover

    Documented supporting details: The cover and booklet photographs of the 1992 Roadrunner CD preserve the dark-rose motif, the band portraits and the inscriptions on the physical release. Booklet image 8 prints a German aphorism attributed to Arthur Schopenhauer, rejecting the desire of the dead to return to life. This is a philosophical paratext actually printed with the album. The quotation in the booklet does not prove that Krull read the original philosophical work, nor can it be identified as the direct source of every song.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.
    2. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 1.
    4. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 8.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    106. Nagual, 1993

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In Copenhagen, a fanzine interviewer tried to render the title as “Deathwish”

    Documented supporting details: Krull specifically states that, against the band’s wishes, the German title Todessehnsucht was changed to an English title for the American market; he would have preferred to retain the original. Alex explicitly links the early use of German lyrics to the 1992 album, explaining his lyrical approach through serious historical subjects, the world wars and inspiration from Expressionist literature. Alex clarifies that the German word cannot simply be rendered exactly into English and that the album was called “Longing for Death” in America. This should be considered alongside later statements about the boundary between Blue Blood and Hallucinations. [p. 7, the title Todessehnsucht / Longing for Death] The interviewer attempts to translate the German title Todessehnsucht as “Deathwish”.

    Source details:

    1. Nagual, 1993
    2. Orpheus Spiliotopoulos (Eleni also asks questions) · Alex Krull – interview from the Atlantis period · Metal Temple · 2004-06-13
    3. Unverified author · Interview: Atrocity (2013) – Alex Krull · The Moshville Times · 2013-04; exact day unverified
    4. Markus Endres · Atrocity – Interview mit Alex Krull und Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer zu “Okkult II” · metal.de · 2018-07-18
    5. Michael (article byline; full name unverified) · Atrocity with Alexander Krull (vocals) – interview · MetalBite · 2023-02-02

    Source-critical limits: A contemporary interview is a participant’s or journalist’s account. Personal memories, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification from a label’s records or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    107. Bericht der Bundesregierung über die Lage der Medien 1994, Drucksache 12/8587

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In 1992, 131.8 million CDs were sold in German shops, up from 104.2 million the year before

    Documented supporting details: The recording-industry trade association’s unit counts, as summarised in the federal report, are 104.2 million CDs in 1991 and 131.8 million in 1992; 78.4 million prerecorded cassettes in 1991 and 58.2 million in 1992; 23.8 million LPs in 1991 and only 5.1 million in 1992. According to the federal report, CDs represented 62 per cent of the value of the recorded-music market in 1991, 74 per cent in 1992 and 79 per cent in 1993 (PDF p. 203, table B 123–124 and analysis).

    Source details:

    1. Bericht der Bundesregierung über die Lage der Medien 1994, Drucksache 12/8587 · German Bundestag · 1994-10-20
    2. Dutch Pearce · Analog Archives – Dima Andreyuk and the Tape Dealer (1984–1994) · Decibel Magazine · 2020-08-31
    3. SKEEZICKS – Als Hardcore neu war · Ox-Fanzine #159 · Online interview from around 2021
    4. History of Phonograms 1951–2000 – 1992 DCC / MiniDisc · IFPI Greece · Later industry chronology

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not establish direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    108. Nuclear Blast Records – About Us — Nuclear Blast Records

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In the recollections of Dima Andreyuk and Mark Riddick, a cassette came with an envelope, an address and a letter

    Documented supporting details: The magazine’s own account says that in 1987 it became the first German fanzine distributed nationwide. In his separate introductory testimony, Mark Riddick recalls that cassette trading between fans, bands and small distributors in the early 1990s enabled people like him to hear extreme music that was less readily available through mainstream shops. This is Riddick’s personal experience as recounted in 2020, not evidence for every European city’s or band’s distribution history. The distinction also requires examining the specific Atrocity issues from 1992 against their original sources: an editor’s memories of 1984 cannot be treated as proof of specific interviews from 1992. Later Massacre Records announcements concerning the album are separate documents whose evidentiary value must be distinguished from that of contemporary interviews.

    Source details:

    1. Nuclear Blast Records – About Us · Nuclear Blast Records · Official label history
    2. Century Media Records – The Label · Century Media Records · Official label history
    3. Metal Hammer, 2017
    4. Rock Hard – Über uns · Rock Hard · Official editorial retrospective
    5. Die harten Anfänge: METAL HAMMER in den Achtzigern · Metal Hammer · 2014-09-23
    6. Massacre Records – label identification · MusicBrainz · Database record, updated 2019
    7. Dutch Pearce · Analog Archives – Dima Andreyuk and the Tape Dealer (1984–1994) · Decibel Magazine · 2020-08-31
    8. Peardrop, 1990
    9. Underground Empire, 1991
    10. Depth of Pain, 1992

    Source-critical limits: Local-history, archival and institutional accounts describe the documented past of the region; they do not establish direct personal creative influence on Atrocity’s later music. Details reported as tradition must not be turned into certain dates.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    109. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — Small but important differences survived between the physical editions

    Documented supporting details: Both spellings of the catalogue number can be read on the back of the original Roadrunner CD. The printed total playing time of 47:22 and the 47:15 obtained by adding the registered track lengths are separate data points; their discrepancy does not prove a different mix. The original CD booklet is the primary source for authorship credits. The cassette image lists ten tracks and does not contain Archangel, which appears as track eleven and a bonus on the Roadrunner CD. Images 05 and 06 depict both physical sides of the original audio cassette, marked RR 9128 4 / side 1 and 2. The order of the songs is also given in the original booklet.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 1.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 4.
    4. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    5. Discogs · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht. Descriptions of official releases, 14 records.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    110. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Metal Mind Productions, 2007. MASS CD 1072 DG, booklet retrospective.

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In 1992, the record set out across several territories and formats

    Documented supporting details: The original CD from 1992 contains eleven tracks, whereas the side labels of the cassette and Roadracer LP contain ten. Archangel is a bonus track on the original CD. Dates and territories assigned to the different formats depend on surviving release records rather than the appearance of the track listing alone. The cassette photograph lists ten titles and excludes Archangel, track eleven on the Roadrunner CD. The original cassette and LP side labels for the Roadracer RR 9128 edition document a ten-track release (source identifier: S-BK-1992-ROADRACER-02–04).

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Metal Mind Productions, 2007. MASS CD 1072 DG, booklet retrospective.
    2. ATROCITY – Todessehnsucht: original studio work and credits in the label’s account · Massacre Records – label news page, 07/2020 · 2020-07 (website month)
    3. Discogs · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht. Descriptions of official releases, 14 records.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    111. The release year and autumn tour dates — limits of a precise day-of-release claim

    Related passage: Two Calendars — In the band’s history, 1992 is the year of its Roadrunner album

    Documented supporting details: The band’s official biography dates the Roadrunner release of Todessehnsucht to 1992. Its autumn tour calendar lists Paris on 19 October, Stockholm on 25 October, Copenhagen on 26 October, followed by Berlin, Hamburg, Ludwigsburg and Munich on 27–30 October. A release date to the exact day is less securely established than these entries. The autumn section specifies Paris/Espace Ornano on 19 October; Katwijk/Scrum Club on the 20th; Leuven/Lido on the 21st; Tilburg/Noorderligt on the 22nd; Stockholm/Fryshuset (also Therion) on the 25th; Copenhagen/Pumpehuset on the 26th; Berlin/Huxley’s on the 27th; Hamburg/Markthalle on the 28th; Ludwigsburg/Rockfabrik on the 29th; and Munich/Nachtwerk on the 30th.

    Source details:

    1. ATROCITY – Bio (official band biography) · Atrocity – official website · Original online publication date not supplied
    2. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive
    3. Underground Empire, 1991

    Source-critical limits: The album’s release in 1992 is supported, but no contemporary Roadrunner evidence dated specifically 22 September is known. A retrospective release date cannot become a primary witness.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    113. Discrepancies between the 1992 printed tour advertisement and the later concert archive

    Related passage: Two Calendars — The contemporary EB/METRONOM advertisement lists Berlin, Hamburg, Ludwigsburg and Munich for 27–30 November

    Documented supporting details: The contemporary advertisement printed on page 41 of EB/METRONOM in 1992 lists the Deicide–Unleashed–Atrocity–Malevolent Creation tour stops in Berlin, Hamburg, Ludwigsburg and Munich for 27–30 November 1992. By contrast, the band’s later official concert archive places events in the same four cities at the end of October. The printed programme records what was advertised in advance; the later database offers reconstructed performance dates. They must not be silently conflated. The discrepancy concerning the date in Warsaw likewise remains an open historical question.

    Source details:

    1. EB/METRONOM, 1992
    2. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive

    Source-critical limits: A claim can be considered supported only to the extent demonstrated by the particular source passage examined. A bibliographical record or reference alone does not prove every associated historical detail.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    114. Nagual, 1993

    Related passage: Two Calendars — In Copenhagen, a Nagual contributor spoke to Krull on the occasion of a show with Deicide and Gorefest

    Documented supporting details: The editorial introduction accompanying the printed 1993 Nagual interview says that Atrocity gave the interview on the occasion of a concert in Copenhagen together with Deicide and Gorefest. The conversation, recorded outdoors amid noise, captures Krull’s own statements. An interviewer’s question about stage-diving by members of the audience is not an official venue regulation. The band’s later performance archive lists Karlsruhe with Morgoth in spring 1993, German and Swiss dates with Dark Millennium in April, and Kölleda with Pyogenesis in June. Those are separate retrospective calendar entries.

    Source details:

    1. Nagual, 1993
    2. ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive

    Source-critical limits: A contemporary interview is a participant’s or journalist’s account. Personal memories, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification from a label’s records or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    115. Aberration, 1993

    Related passage: Two Calendars — Atrocity undertook the tour after completing its second album

    Documented supporting details: Accounts of reactions experienced at concerts immediately after 1992 are mixed. Many listeners who knew the album appreciated its differences, but Krull perceived the mood of one particular Paris evening as less successful, in part because the band members themselves were tired. The introductory editorial text says the interviewer met Atrocity while the group was touring Europe to promote Todessehnsucht and spoke with singer Alex Krull after a performance in Paris.

    Source details:

    1. Aberration, 1993

    Source-critical limits: A contemporary interview is a participant’s or journalist’s account. Personal memories, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification from a label’s records or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    121. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 1. booklet image.

    Related passage: Two Calendars — Alongside the disc, the release’s visual imagery also travelled

    Documented supporting details: The original Roadrunner CD cover presents an organic visual motif of brownish-red roses; booklet image 8 contains a thought attributed to Arthur Schopenhauer rejecting a wish by the dead to return. The title track and its reprise on track ten can be traced in the printed track list. Connecting the artwork, aphorism and structural return is a literary interpretation. The images do not prove that every listener understood the completed album in the same way.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 1.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 8.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    123. Eckart Maronde — Atrocity – Interview mit Alexander Krull zu “Die Gottlosen Jahre”

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — In 2012 Krull recalled the Augsburg incident in which, according to his account, youth-protection officials interpreted the word Todessehnsucht as an exhortation and attempted to stop the album-release…

    Documented supporting details: In Eckart Maronde’s 2012 interview for metal.de, Krull tells a separate, retrospective personal story about how the title Todessehnsucht was received in Augsburg. According to him, a youth-protection interpretation misread the album-release poster as a call to suicide, and the possibility of cancelling the event was raised. In the contemporary Nagual conversation, the meaning of the German title also had to be explained within a different linguistic context. This is the speaker’s version of events; no separate Augsburg administrative document has been established in the surviving material.

    Source details:

    1. Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Interview mit Alexander Krull zu “Die Gottlosen Jahre” · metal.de · 2012-05-02
    2. Nagual, 1993

    Source-critical limits: A contemporary interview is a participant’s or journalist’s account. Personal memories, plans for the future and estimated figures are not equivalent to independent verification from a label’s records or studio logs.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    124. ATROCITY – Bio (official band history)

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — After early death metal, Atrocity’s records moved towards increasingly different sounds

    Documented supporting details: According to one interviewee’s own memories as a listener, the overly fast death metal of the first album appealed less, while the darker atmosphere of the second was particularly attractive. Blut and Calling the Rain remained personal favourites. The many hours spent with samplers in the studio in 1996, later touring technology and festival performance practices all belong to later years: they do not demonstrate that the same equipment, studio methods or stage devices were used for the 1992 Todessehnsucht recording. Retrospective evaluations of the later period also discuss the contrasting sounds of cover versions, assessments of commercial success made after the fact, guest vocals and visual presentation. They are not eyewitness accounts of the 1992 studio recording.

    Source details:

    1. ATROCITY – Bio (official band biography) · Atrocity – official website · Original online publication date not supplied
    2. Atrocity – Nuclear Blast: early label background on the band · Nuclear Blast – official label artist profile · Original publication date unknown
    3. The documentary’s full authorial credits have not been established · Die Gottlosen Jahre – three-hour documentary on Atrocity’s career · Atrocity official discography, DVD (2012) · 2012 (DVD)
    4. Author unverified on original page · Atrocity – workoholics on tour (Alex Krull) · Schwermetall.ch · around 2007–2008; original day unknown
    5. Unverified author · Interview: Atrocity (2013) – Alex Krull · The Moshville Times · 2013-04; exact day unverified

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    126. DJ In Extremis — interview with Alex Krull and Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — In 2004, during the Atlantis period, Krull looked back on the first two albums as part of a long and experimental career

    Documented supporting details: On the original website, alongside preparations for a 2018 release after 2017, the band mentions the 25th anniversary of the 1992 release of Todessehnsucht, regards the album as a milestone in its own career, and announces plans for further historical interviews. Krull later discusses the archive used for the documentary: according to his account, work began in 2007 and was originally intended as a much smaller best-of-style project, but the appeal for material prompted musicians, friends and acquaintances to send a considerable number of old photographs and films. In later answers about composition and studio work on Atlantis, Tosso speaks of balancing melody and brutality and Krull of jointly developing the different band members’ ideas. They explicitly describe the creative process for the 2004 album, however; their observations cannot be transferred to the division of songwriting credits on the 1992 tracks.

    Source details:

    1. DJ In Extremis · Atrocity (VO) – interview with Alex Krull and Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer · Spirit of Metal / DJ In Extremis · 2004-05
    2. ATROCITY – Bio (official band biography) · Atrocity – official website · Original online publication date not supplied
    3. Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Interview mit Alexander Krull zu “Die Gottlosen Jahre” · metal.de · 2012-05-02
    4. Markus Endres · Atrocity – Interview mit Alex Krull und Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer zu “Okkult II” · metal.de · 2018-07-18
    5. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    6. Michael (article byline; full name unverified) · Atrocity with Alexander Krull (vocals) – interview · MetalBite · 2023-02-02
    7. Atrocity website editorial team – individual unverified · ATROCITY – 25 years “TODESSEHNSUCHT” album & history report · Atrocity official website · around early 2018; precise date unknown
    8. The documentary’s full authorial credits have not been established · Die Gottlosen Jahre – three-hour documentary on Atrocity’s career · Atrocity official discography, DVD (2012) · 2012 (DVD)

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    127. Author not identified

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — The four recordings from 1991 remained in existence after the album

    Documented supporting details: The four pre-production recordings from 1991 appear in later reissue documentation as tapes of separate origin. A release planned for 2021 but eventually realised in 2022 does not transform the demo recording into an album release from 1992. Three of the four demo songs were made available only later; disruption in vinyl manufacturing associated with the coronavirus pandemic delayed an issue initially expected in November 2021 until January 2022. Krull had kept the original demo tapes at Mastersound Studio. Unspoken Names had previously resurfaced and been remastered.

    Source details:

    1. Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26
    2. Alexandra Michels · ATROCITY – “Unspoken Names (Demo 1991)”: overview of the original 1991 advance recordings · Rock Hard – Alexandra Michels · 2021-11-25

    Source-critical limits: A later interview or recollection records the speaker’s perspective. Musicians who joined after 1992 cannot be treated as direct witnesses to the 1992 recording sessions.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    129. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, 2. booklet image.

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — The title theme must wait until the tenth track to return under its own name

    Documented supporting details: The original CD track listing places Todessehnsucht first, its reprise tenth, and Archangel eleventh as a bonus track. Reading the return of the title theme as an aspect of the work’s structure is an interpretation of the recording. It provides no independent evidence for the motives behind the recording or the decision to add a bonus.

    Source details:

    1. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.
    2. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 4.
    3. Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.

    Source-critical limits: The original format’s inscriptions, track listings and credit lines are primary documents. They do not independently establish the reasons for recording decisions, and illegible fine print must not be filled in by conjecture.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    131. Concert Archives: Blind Guardian and Iced Earth at Rockfabrik, Ludwigsburg, 20 September 1992 (retrospective concert database). A contemporary text printed from EB/Metronom #39, p. 42, confirms the date and venue, but the merged columns make the attribution of performers uncertain.

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The Stuttgart concert season of 1992 unfolds through different musical evenings in a venue calendar published much later

    Documented supporting details: The concert database records Blind Guardian and Iced Earth appearing at Ludwigsburg’s Rockfabrik on 20 September 1992. This is a programme entry registered later, not a direct venue log, ticket or eyewitness statement from 1992. The reference to the Rockfabrik date in the narrative does not mean that Atrocity attended that evening or came into contact with members of the performing bands.

    Source details:

    1. Concert Archives: Blind Guardian and Iced Earth, Rockfabrik, Ludwigsburg, 20 September 1992 (retrospective concert database). Contemporary text printed from EB/Metronom issue 39, p. 42, supports the date and venue; the overlapping columns leave the attribution of the performers uncertain.

      The reproduced text from the contemporary magazine supports the date and venue; the original column layout still needs to be checked before the performers can be assigned with certainty.

    Source-critical limits: A retrospective concert calendar documents the venue’s programme. It does not, by itself, establish an Atrocity performance or any particular personal encounter on the date in question.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    132. POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004; LKA Longhorn’s retrospective concert list published in 2006, p. 117: 21 September 1992 — Testament; 22 September — GWAR. This is not a 1992 poster.

    Related passage: Three Locations for the Recording — The Stuttgart concert season of 1992 unfolds through different musical evenings in a venue calendar published much later

    Documented supporting details: The Longhorn’s retrospective concert list published in 2006 names Testament for 21 September 1992 and GWAR for 22 September in Stuttgart. It also lists Overkill in February, Prong and Gods of Grind/Carcass in March, Paradise Lost in April, Obituary in June, Sodom in October and Helmet in December. The later institutional calendar documents the variety of the venue’s programming. It does not prove that Atrocity attended personally or that the album went on sale on 22 September 1992.

    Source details:

    1. POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004; LKA Longhorn’s own retrospective concert list from 2006, p. 117. 21 September 1992: Testament; 22 September: GWAR. The 2006 list is not a concert poster issued in 1992.

    Source-critical limits: Different venues’ schedules and recollections cannot be conflated into a single verified concert history; an advertised performance and the presence of members of another band are separate claims.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    133. 22 September 1992 — retrospective catalogue date, not a contemporary label receipt

    Related passage: Two Calendars — Later release registers list Atrocity’s second album under 1992

    Documented supporting details: Later catalogue records alone link the release dates of two different albums, Atrocity’s and Cannibal Corpse’s, to 22 September 1992. The date assigned to the Cannibal Corpse release does not establish the first retail day of Atrocity’s Roadrunner album.

    Source details:

    1. Cannibal Corpse: Tomb of the Mutilated. Metal Blade Records, US edition; 22 September 1992. MusicBrainz – retrospective release record. An original, day-specific label announcement from 1992 was not directly verified.
    2. Encyclopaedia Metallum – Cannibal Corpse, Tomb of the Mutilated. Supplementary retrospective album entry; does not establish a direct connection with Atrocity.

    Source-critical limits: The album’s release in 1992 is supported, but no contemporary Roadrunner evidence dated specifically 22 September is known. A retrospective release date cannot become a primary witness.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    134. Schnarrenberg, 22–23 September 1992 — indirectly published daily weather records

    Related passage: Two Calendars — The difference between the September days is particularly striking in the readings from the Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg station

    Documented supporting details: The indirectly published observations from the Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg station give 12.9/27.7 °C as minimum/maximum on 22 September 1992, 3.4 mm of rain and 9.3 hours of sunshine; the next day records 13.7/18.3 °C, 1.6 mm and 0.9 hours respectively. These two days were not identical, and the observation station was not at the studio in Fautspach.

    Source details:

    1. Wetter Ludwigsburg: historical daily observations for Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg derived from DWD (station code 04928), September 1992. 22 Sept.: minimum 12.9 °C, maximum 27.7 °C, rainfall 3.4 mm, sunshine 9.3 hours; 23 Sept.: minimum 13.7 °C, maximum 18.3 °C, rainfall 1.6 mm, sunshine 0.9 hours. Daily summaries, not observations of the album’s retail-release hour or the weather at Fautspach. The original DWD daily dataset for station 04928 can be identified, but comparison with the two raw daily records remains outstanding.

      Source location: DWD Climate Data Center, station 04928, 1992. The precise measurement intervals have yet to be checked against the primary data.

    Source-critical limits: The Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg readings come from a secondary publication derived from DWD data. The original dataset for station 04928 has been identified, but the individual raw daily records have not been checked separately. These figures do not prove the musicians’ personal experience of the weather.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    Critical and review notes · 17

    092. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013)

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In the opening, Krull set the image of a leaf separating from its branch to Röderer’s music

    Documented supporting details: According to the critic, the guitars develop the melodic basis of later songs in response to the notes of the opening motif. The transition into Godless Years is singled out, as is the return of the main theme towards the end of the record. The writer highlights the dark introduction, the pairing of Godless Years and Unspoken Names, the choir-like effect of Sky Turned Red, and the compressed structure of Necropolis.

    Source details:

    1. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 97%

      Slow distorted opening motif, live-sounding drums, the functions of refrain and reprise; the Wagner comparison is a listener’s observation.

    2. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 90%

      Symphonic opening, rhythmic vocals, guitar solo and recurring introductory motif.

    3. Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

      Variations of the opening motif, the transition into Godless Years, a classical association in Sky Turned Red and the more direct structure of Necropolis.

    4. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    094. Christian Popp — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past)

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — When Godless Years begins, images of mortality give way to images of humanity’s own power

    Documented supporting details: Compared with Hallucinations, Popp hears the album’s technical sound as more organised. He singles out the dark introduction, the Godless Years / Unspoken Names pairing, the chorus-like impact of Sky Turned Red and the concentrated structure of Necropolis.

    Source details:

    1. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    2. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    096. Fabien — Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — On the demo, Unspoken Names had to provide a title for all four tracks; on the finished album, it comes third and has time to linger over the unspeakable

    Documented supporting details: Fabien distinguishes the more broken-up tempo changes of Necropolis and Sky Turned Red from the accelerating, aggressive pulse of Unspoken Names and Triumph at Dawn, and hears the Death cover Archangel as a tribute by the singer and band. For Fabien, Unspoken Names and A Prison Called Earth exemplify the technical writing, while Defiance and Necropolis are layered pieces that reveal their value on closer listening and demonstrate the material’s lasting quality.

    Source details:

    1. Fabien · Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien · Spirit of Metal · 2007-03-26 · 15/20

      Technical death metal framed by opening and reprise; Unspoken Names, A Prison Called Earth and the CD bonus.

    2. ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

      An interpretation of the German title, classical colouring, instrumental performance and reservations about the coherence of the sound.

    3. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 90%

      Symphonic opening, rhythmic vocals, guitar solo and recurring introductory motif.

    4. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    098. ElectricOne — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne)

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — In Defiance, violence tests and attempts to break the will; the booklet credits Röderer and Scharf with the music

    Documented supporting details: In this critic’s view Defiance and, to a lesser degree, Triumph at Dawn are weaker than the other compositions. The more fragmented changes of tempo in Necropolis and Sky Turned Red are distinguished from the rapidly moving, aggressive pulse in Unspoken Names and Triumph at Dawn. The critic regards the cover of Death’s Archangel as a tribute to the singer and band.

    Source details:

    1. ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

      An interpretation of the German title, classical colouring, instrumental performance and reservations about the coherence of the sound.

    2. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    3. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 97%

      Slow distorted opening motif, live-sounding drums, the functions of refrain and reprise; the Wagner comparison is a listener’s observation.

    4. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 90%

      Symphonic opening, rhythmic vocals, guitar solo and recurring introductory motif.

    5. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    100. ElectricOne — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne)

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — During the ninety seconds of Introduction, the album’s sound changes direction before Sky Turned Red begins

    Documented supporting details: Later reviews offer different interpretations of the mid-album Introduction and the choir-like sound of Sky Turned Red. One writer makes an atmospheric comparison with Wagner and Götterdämmerung; Christian Popp is more concerned with the structure and dark sound of these passages. According to the 1992 booklet, the lyrics to Introduction are credited to Krull, its arrangement to Atrocity, and the music for Sky Turned Red to Röderer and Scharf. The Wagner comparison does not identify a verified location in a score or an actual musical quotation taken from it.

    Source details:

    1. ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

      An interpretation of the German title, classical colouring, instrumental performance and reservations about the coherence of the sound.

    2. Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

      Variations of the opening motif, the transition into Godless Years, a classical association in Sky Turned Red and the more direct structure of Necropolis.

    3. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    4. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 97%

      Slow distorted opening motif, live-sounding drums, the functions of refrain and reprise; the Wagner comparison is a listener’s observation.

    5. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    102. ElectricOne — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne)

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — Necropolis moves from images of human destruction towards the cemetery

    Documented supporting details: Maronde highlights the choir-like vocal interlude in Sky Turned Red and the structure of A Prison Called Earth, which opens with keyboard chords before moving into forceful guitar chords. The choral arrangement in Sky Turned Red is associated with classical or operatic tension, while Necropolis is described as having a more direct death-metal structure. Maronde considers the demo versions of Sky Turned Red, Unspoken Names, Defiance and A Prison Called Earth substantially the same four songs as their album counterparts from the following year, albeit with pre-production differences in details and sound. In the critic’s more abstract language, rhythmic phrasing and the anticipation of the vibration of individual notes create almost “narrative” motion. Guitar lines are not merely a block-like backdrop, but trace melodic storylines above a complex rhythmic framework.

    Source details:

    1. ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

      An interpretation of the German title, classical colouring, instrumental performance and reservations about the coherence of the sound.

    2. Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

      Variations of the opening motif, the transition into Godless Years, a classical association in Sky Turned Red and the more direct structure of Necropolis.

    3. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    4. Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Unspoken Names (Demo 1991) – Review · metal.de · 2022-01-22

      Analysis of the four songs on the 1991 Unspoken Names demo, compared with the 1992 album versions.

    5. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 97%

      Slow distorted opening motif, live-sounding drums, the functions of refrain and reprise; the Wagner comparison is a listener’s observation.

    6. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 90%

      Symphonic opening, rhythmic vocals, guitar solo and recurring introductory motif.

    7. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    104. Fabien — Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien

    Related passage: The Ten Tracks and What Follows Them — The opening theme by Röderer returns in the tenth piece

    Documented supporting details: The reviewer names A Prison Called Earth as a personal favourite, hears the reprise as the return of the opening theme, and regards Archangel as a respectful cover of Death. The cover of Death’s Archangel at the end of the CD edition receives particular praise. Studio and producer credits cited by the reviewer are critical reporting: they can be checked against the original booklet, but the words of praise express the reviewer’s own judgment.

    Source details:

    1. Fabien · Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien · Spirit of Metal · 2007-03-26 · 15/20

      Technical death metal framed by opening and reprise; Unspoken Names, A Prison Called Earth and the CD bonus.

    2. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    112. Christian Popp’s 2018 review and the release day published retrospectively

    Related passage: Two Calendars — In the band’s history, 1992 is the year of its Roadrunner album

    Documented supporting details: In a metal.de review dated 3 October 2018, Christian Popp gave the album 9/10 and recalled his own interest in buying it in 1992 because of the cover. The release date of 22 September 1992 printed in the article is retrospective information, not a contemporary Roadrunner confirmation. The retrospective data entry identifies 22 September 1992 as the release day, but that does not itself make it a primary release document.

    Source details:

    1. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    Source-critical limits: The album’s release in 1992 is supported, but no contemporary Roadrunner evidence dated specifically 22 September is known. A retrospective release date cannot become a primary witness.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    116. Disposable Underground, 1993

    Related passage: Two Calendars — An early 1993 review had already noticed the shift between the two Atrocity albums: in the writer’s judgment, death, grind and doom were more tightly interwoven than on the debut

    Documented supporting details: A contemporary 1993 review praises a closer fusion of death, grind and doom compared with the debut, while another review foregrounds the connections between guitar runs and chord sequences and the quieter vocal passages. These are distinct writers’ opinions, not the band’s official genre definition. The guitar analysis particularly stresses the interlocking and partly parallel melodic roles of rapid single-note runs and powerful chord progressions. The critic also responds positively to the more restrained, “European”-sounding quieter vocals.

    Source details:

    1. Disposable Underground, 1993
    2. No author credited · ATROCITY – Longing for Death (standalone undated online review) · Death Metal Underground / deathmetal.org · No date · The original review’s publication date is unverified

      Interweaving variations of themes, chromatic guitar passages, rhythmic contrasts and production limitations.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    117. Nathan Robinson’s retrospective — the Taste of Sin rating is not the album’s rating

    Related passage: Two Calendars — In the new millennium the early album increasingly became a yardstick for judging Atrocity’s later changes

    Documented supporting details: The author calls Longing for Death a personal favourite and a major album in extreme metal, but does not invariably like Atrocity’s subsequent changes of genre; he heard Willenskraft as a return and Werk 80 as another change of direction. In his view, Unspoken Names and A Prison Called Earth exemplify technical writing, while Defiance and Necropolis are layered compositions that become more rewarding on closer subsequent listening, giving the whole release lasting value. He values the skilled instrumental playing, complex arrangements and seemingly perilous speed. Fabien emphasises the development from the technical death metal of Hallucinations towards a denser, more expansive second album with a broader musical vocabulary.

    Source details:

    1. Nathan Robinson · Atrocity – Taste of Sin (retrospective reference in a review of a different release) · Metal-Rules.com · 2000-12-01 · 2,7/5 (Taste of Sin)

      The writer uses Longing for Death as a personal favourite when judging the later EP.

    2. Fabien · Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien · Spirit of Metal · 2007-03-26 · 15/20

      Technical death metal framed by opening and reprise; Unspoken Names, A Prison Called Earth and the CD bonus.

    3. ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

      An interpretation of the German title, classical colouring, instrumental performance and reservations about the coherence of the sound.

    Source-critical limits: The 2.7/5 rating belongs to the Taste of Sin EP, not to the Todessehnsucht album. This documents a critic’s or listener’s judgment and later recollection, not the band’s intentions, the entire 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    118. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008)

    Related passage: Two Calendars — On forums and music databases in the 2000s, listeners tried to put more and more of the musical details into words

    Documented supporting details: Three preserved listener reviews on Encyclopaedia Metallum register different emphases. One praises the symphonic opening, guitar solos, alternations between thrash-like and atmospheric passages, and the return of the opening motif. Another discovered Michael Schwarz’s rhythmic precision and the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red through repeated listens, but regarded the operatic guest vocals as too quiet. The third focuses on the relationship between complexity and dark atmosphere. These are personal reviews from different dates, not a contemporary consensus.

    Source details:

    1. MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 90%

      Symphonic opening, rhythmic vocals, guitar solo and recurring introductory motif.

    2. Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 96%

      Schwarz’s rhythms, the differently scaled sections of Sky Turned Red, and an operatic guest voice judged too quiet.

    3. arrrrrrrach: Longing for some fuckin amazing death metal!! (31 July 2004) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 95%

      Thrash riffs, blast beats, slower atmosphere and Archangel taken together.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    119. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013)

    Related passage: Two Calendars — In time, attention also turned to instrumental details

    Documented supporting details: The review compares Todessehnsucht with a number of later bands and with the albums The Red in the Sky Is Ours and Unquestionable Presence. Such analogies do not automatically establish historical influence. A central argument is that bass and rhythm section hold together guitar motifs with complex and sometimes unusual structures: the tempos, transitions, keyboard interludes and cuts supposedly produce a coherent form despite the heaviness. According to this critic, guitars develop the later songs’ melodic basis in response to the notes of the opening motif; the transition into Godless Years and the return of the main theme towards the end are singled out. Wizard regards Atrocity’s second album as an outstanding fusion of German death metal with thrash and technical death metal.

    Source details:

    1. SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum · 97%

      Slow distorted opening motif, live-sounding drums, the functions of refrain and reprise; the Wagner comparison is a listener’s observation.

    2. Wizard · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht · Sputnikmusic · 2011-09-24 · 4,5/5

      Bass and drums hold the guitars’ complex movement together.

    3. Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

      Variations of the opening motif, the transition into Godless Years, a classical association in Sky Turned Red and the more direct structure of Necropolis.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    120. Christian Popp — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past)

    Related passage: Two Calendars — Many expected a different musical world from the dried roses on the cover

    Documented supporting details: The metal.de writer in 2018 describes a personal memory prompted by the cover and singles out A Prison Called Earth; a later listener review reports having expected death/doom because of the artwork but heard mostly death metal instead. These are separate viewpoints, not evidence of uniform reception. The dried roses on the cover, together with the band’s later gothic direction, led the listener to anticipate a death/doom–gothic mixture. On listening, however, they found the slower, more melodic passages relatively occasional and the dominant musical language to be death metal.

    Source details:

    1. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    2. agymosott09 · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (AOTD reader review, forum message) · Index Fórum – Metal Hammer H · 227257 · 2026-08-26 · 77/100

      The rose cover and the later gothic reputation suggested something different to the listener from the predominantly death-metal material.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    122. Christian Popp — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past)

    Related passage: Two Calendars — Alongside the disc, the release’s visual imagery also travelled

    Documented supporting details: The reviewer names A Prison Called Earth as a favourite, takes the reprise as the return of the opening theme, and hears Archangel as a respectful cover of Death. Another listener, prompted by the dried-rose artwork and the group’s later gothic reputation, expected a death/doom–gothic mixture, but heard relatively little slow melodic music and regarded the album as predominantly death metal.

    Source details:

    1. Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03 · 9/10

      The cover’s appeal as a reason to buy the record; a more organised sound, praise for A Prison Called Earth, and reservations about Defiance and Triumph at Dawn.

    2. agymosott09 · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (AOTD reader review, forum message) · Index Fórum – Metal Hammer H · 227257 · 2026-08-26 · 77/100

      The rose cover and the later gothic reputation suggested something different to the listener from the predominantly death-metal material.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    125. Nathan Robinson — Atrocity – Taste of Sin (retrospective reference in a review of a different release)

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — After early death metal, Atrocity’s records moved towards increasingly different sounds

    Documented supporting details: The reviewer calls Longing for Death a personal favourite and an album of great importance to extreme metal. He does not always appreciate the band’s later changes of genre, regarding Willenskraft as a return towards earlier territory and Werk 80 as another change of direction. For the history of Todessehnsucht, the retrospective judgment and this layer of reception from 2000 are the relevant evidence.

    Source details:

    1. Nathan Robinson · Atrocity – Taste of Sin (retrospective reference in a review of a different release) · Metal-Rules.com · 2000-12-01 · 2,7/5 (Taste of Sin)

      The writer uses Longing for Death as a personal favourite when judging the later EP.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    128. Eckart Maronde — Atrocity – Unspoken Names (Demo 1991) – Review

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — The four recordings from 1991 remained in existence after the album

    Documented supporting details: According to Maronde, the demo versions of Sky Turned Red, Unspoken Names, Defiance and A Prison Called Earth represent substantially the same four songs as the corresponding album tracks recorded a year later, although their details and sound reveal the pre-production stage. This is NOT a review of the entire Todessehnsucht album and NOT a press article from 1991. It is a review published in 2022 of a demo from 1991, comparing its four early tracks with the finished 1992 album.

    Source details:

    1. Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Unspoken Names (Demo 1991) – Review · metal.de · 2022-01-22

      Analysis of the four songs on the 1991 Unspoken Names demo, compared with the 1992 album versions.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    130. Nicholas Vahdias — Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992)

    Related passage: Memories That Became Part of the Album — The title theme must wait until the tenth track to return under its own name

    Documented supporting details: In the critic’s own abstract vocabulary, the rhythmic phrasing and the anticipation of the vibration of individual notes create an almost “narrative” movement. Guitar lines do not merely form a solid block in the background; they draw melodic storylines above the complex rhythmic structure.

    Source details:

    1. Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

      Variations of the opening motif, the transition into Godless Years, a classical association in Sky Turned Red and the more direct structure of Necropolis.

    Source-critical limits: This records a critic’s or listener’s own aesthetic judgment and later recollection. It does not establish the band’s intentions, the full 1992 press response or a representative listener survey.

    Return to the narrative · Note on a separate page

    Complete source bibliography

    Complete source bibliography

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 2.

    Underground Empire, 1991

    Aberration, 1993

    Author unidentified · ATROCITY – Brutal und in die Fresse (interview with Alex Krull) · Rock Hard, Vol. 416 · Rock Hard Vol. 416 · 2022-01-26

    Geschichte der Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Stiftsmusik Stuttgart · Institutional online historical overview

    Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · La Didone abbandonata (Stuttgart 1763) – Niccolò Jommelli · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg / Prof. Dr. Joachim Kremer · Specialist historical account; covering 1753–1769

    Von Herzögen, Schlössern und Kasernen – a history of Ludwigsburg · Stadt Ludwigsburg – municipal administration · 1704–1992 (overview of local history; online publication date not specified)

    Die Gemeinde Althütte – the municipal history of Althütte and Sechselberg · Gemeinde Althütte, Rems-Murr-Kreis · Municipal historical overview

    Stuttgart schreibt Geschichte – official historical overview of Stuttgart · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · 2020-07-21

    300 Jahre – 300 Dinge: Planstadt Ludwigsburg · Ludwigsburg Museum · from 1704 to modern times (online museum exhibition)

    Stadt geworden! – selection of sources on the granting of town status · Stadtarchiv Ludwigsburg / municipal publications · 2018 (digital presentation of urban history)

    Otto Schifferer · Die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung Ludwigsburgs von der Gründung der Stadt bis zum Beginn des 2. Weltkrieges · Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, Heft 20 (1968), S. 53–80.

    Fautsbach: Sechselberg, Althütte – archival depiction from 1686 · Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg, Hauptstaatsarchiv Stuttgart · 1686 (original cartographic/pictorial source)

    Heimat-Museum Althütte – work, glassworks, local water supply · Heimatkulturverein Althütte · 1988 museum opening and earlier local history

    BKZ – article author unidentified · Holpriger Start in eine gemeinsame Zukunft – Fautspach/Sechselberg municipal reform · Backnanger Kreiszeitung (BKZ) · 2021 (retrospective article on the events of 1971–1972)

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, American CD and booklet.

    Ludwigsburger Geschichtsblätter, 2016

    Das S-Bahn Netz im Stuttgarter Raum / frühere industrielle Verkehrsachsen · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart – historical statistics · statistical historical study published in 2009

    Geschichte der Stuttgarter Musikschule I (1857–1936) · Stuttgarter Musikschule · Historical institutional web page

    Stadtentwicklung Ludwigsburg – from garrison to civilian town, Pattonville and 1970–1990 · Stadt Ludwigsburg / urban development study · around 2011 (historical retrospective)

    Werner Brachat-Schwarz · Von 3 auf 11 Millionen – Baden-Württemberg population history · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg / Statistisches Monatsheft · 2018, issue 5 (historical series)

    Zeitreise: Festspiele im Schloss – Ludwigsburger Schlossfestspiele · Staatliche Schlösser und Gärten Baden-Württemberg · historical data for 1932 and 1947

    Total Normahl – punk in the Winnenden/Stuttgart region · Region Stuttgart · 2015-05-07

    Meister seines Fachs – Hans-Peter Haag, Music Circus · Region Stuttgart · later profile, around 2015

    Wie der Punk nach Stuttgart kam – press archive · Stuttgartpunk.de / Simon Steiner research project · 2017 collection page and secondary reproductions

    Innere Entwicklung der Bundesrepublik bis 1989 · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · Overview published around 2002; covering the years 1970–1989

    Ox-Fanzine editorial staff · CHAOS Z – interview about Stuttgart’s punk/new-wave scene · Ox-Fanzine #153 · Online interview from around 2020 (exact publication date unknown)

    SKEEZICKS – Als Hardcore neu war · Ox-Fanzine #159 · Online interview from around 2021

    Geschichte der Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg · Official history of the venue

    Auszeichnungen – Das LKA Longhorn in Stuttgart · LKA Longhorn · Official club history

    Bericht über 20 Jahre Longhorn · LKA Longhorn – archive · Later venue-history account (2004)

    Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg – Geschichte: institutional history · Rockfabrik Ludwigsburg – official local-history page · Online publication date unknown; discusses the institution’s founding in 1983

    ATROCITY – Tour (official historical concert and tour archive) · Atrocity – official website · Historical performances from 1988–1993, presented in a current archive

    Peardrop, 1990

    Holocaust, 1991 or 1992

    Slayer, 1991

    Blasphemous, 1991

    Nagual, 1993

    Melanie Arndt · Auswirkungen der Katastrophe von Tschernobyl auf Deutschland · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2016-04-18 (retrospective); events of 1986

    Maastricht Treaty – founding treaty of the later EU · European Union – official founding agreements · 1992-02-07 (signed), 1993-11-01 (entered into force)

    Wege zur deutschen Einheit – photographs and documents from 1989/90 · Bundesarchiv · Events of 1989–1990; later official archival presentation

    Die harten Anfänge: METAL HAMMER in den Achtzigern · Metal Hammer · 2014-09-23

    Tom G. Warrior – recollections of Celtic Frost’s experiments on Into the Pandemonium · Blabbermouth.net / Blistering.com interview republication · Musician interview from around 2010

    Nuria Hochkirchen · Kreator: 40 Jahre Pleasure to Kill – the thrash/death boundary · Metal Hammer · 2026-04-01

    Rock Hard – Über uns · Rock Hard · Official editorial retrospective

    Depth of Pain, 1992

    The documentary’s full authorial credits have not been established · Die Gottlosen Jahre – three-hour documentary on Atrocity’s career · Atrocity official discography, DVD (2012) · 2012 (DVD)

    Tampa Bay Museum of Metal – Morbid Angel Altars of Madness · Tampa Bay Museum of Metal · Online museum chronology; year discussed: 1989

    Sam Retzer · Scott Burns: The Definition of Death Metal · Tape Op Magazine · Later interview with Scott Burns from 2026

    Death metal och kommunism – Tomas Skogsberg / Sunlight Studios · Proletären · Interview from around 2015

    Nuclear Blast Records – About Us · Nuclear Blast Records · Official label history

    Century Media Records – The Label · Century Media Records · Official label history

    Morgoth (interview from around 2000) – Cursed and dark/gothic cross-influences · Voices from the Darkside · Later participant interview; website date uncertain

    Einstürzende Neubauten – chronology of the 1988 appearance at LKA Longhorn · From The Archives – concert chronology · Original event 1988-07-04

    Der Tag der deutschen Einheit – documents of 3 October 1990 · Bundesarchiv · 1990-10-03 (event), 2015 (presentation)

    Spikehead, 1991

    Nihilistic Holocaust; interviewer’s personal name not established · ATROCITY Interview – Hallucinations From The Past · Nihilistic Holocaust Webzine · 2015-05-09

    Metal Hammer, 2017

    Operation “Ace Guard” – Golfkrieg und deutsche Proteste 1991 · Bundesarchiv · 1991 (event; later archival presentation)

    Dejan Djokić · Über Grenzen und Gedenken – the breakup of Yugoslavia · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2021-11-29; period discussed: 1991–1992

    Jochen Oltmer · “Geduldet” und “rückgeführt”: Schutzsuchende aus den postjugoslawischen Kriegen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2023-01-20; period discussed: 1991–1992

    Atheist interview – 1991 (interview with Steve Flynn) · Disposable Underground, issue 3 (1991) · Online archiving of the original 1991 interview: 19 September 2022.

    Human (1991) – Death, progressive death metal · Relapse Records · Later label overview; year discussed: 1991

    Paradise Lost – Gothic (1991), historical label account · Peaceville Records · Later official band/album account

    My Dying Bride – early Peaceville years and As the Flower Withers · Peaceville Records · Label history of the band

    Greg Mackintosh: Paradise Lost – Live in Ludwigsburg, 1991 · rockmetal.pl · Later musician interview from 2021

    Alexandra Michels · ATROCITY – “Unspoken Names (Demo 1991)”: overview of the original 1991 advance recordings · Rock Hard – Alexandra Michels · 2021-11-25

    POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004 · LKA Longhorn, its own application documentation · Archival compilation from 2006, original concert list covering 1987–2004

    ATROCITY – Bio (official band biography) · Atrocity – official website · Original online publication date not supplied

    Wirtschafts- und Sozialentwicklung in Baden-Württemberg 1993 – figures for 1992 · Statistisches Landesamt Baden-Württemberg · Statistical publication from around 1994 (figures for 1992)

    Bundesbank Monthly Report, December 1992 – The economic scene in Germany · Deutsche Bundesbank · 1992-12 (original publication)

    Thomas Prenzel · Vor 30 Jahren: Die rassistisch motivierten Ausschreitungen von Rostock-Lichtenhagen · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (bpb) · 2022-08-17; events of August 1992

    EB/METRONOM, 1992

    Stuttgart-Mitte – history of the city centre · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · Historical overview of the district

    Atrocity – Concert Archives: concerts between 1990 and 1992 · Concert Archives – community event archive · 1990–1992 (historical concert years)

    Musik der Jahrhunderte – history (1978–1992) · Musik der Jahrhunderte Stuttgart · Official institutional history

    Stuttgart bei Nacht – historical club scene from the 1970s to the 1990s · Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart · Official city study from 2024, database covering 2023 and earlier

    ATROCITY – Todessehnsucht: original studio work and credits in the label’s account · Massacre Records – label news page, 07/2020 · 2020-07 (website month)

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 5.

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 6.

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 7.

    Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Metal Mind Productions, 2007. MASS CD 1072 DG, booklet retrospective.

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 4.

    Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Roadrunner, 1992. RR 9128 2, European CD and booklet.

    Atrocity: Todessehnsucht. Song lyrics; Alex Krull.

    SoundsofDecay: I drift like a falling leaf (4 November 2013) · Encyclopaedia Metallum

    MisterSquiggles: Atrocious Masterpiece (5 April 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum

    Nicholas Vahdias · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Longing for Death) (1992) · Death Metal Underground · 2018-06-16

    Christian Popp · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (Blast From The Past) · metal.de · 2018-10-03

    Pestbesmittad: Refined brutal complexity (21 March 2008) · Encyclopaedia Metallum

    Fabien · Todessehnsucht – Chronique @ Fabien · Spirit of Metal · 2007-03-26

    ElectricOne · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (ElectricOne) · DeBaser · 2007-11-05

    Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Unspoken Names (Demo 1991) – Review · metal.de · 2022-01-22

    Orpheus Spiliotopoulos (Eleni also asks questions) · Alex Krull – interview from the Atlantis period · Metal Temple · 2004-06-13

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 1.

    Atrocity: Longing for Death. Roadrunner, 1992. RRD 9128, booklet image 8.

    Unverified author · Interview: Atrocity (2013) – Alex Krull · The Moshville Times · 2013-04; exact day unverified

    Markus Endres · Atrocity – Interview mit Alex Krull und Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer zu “Okkult II” · metal.de · 2018-07-18

    Michael (article byline; full name unverified) · Atrocity with Alexander Krull (vocals) – interview · MetalBite · 2023-02-02

    Bericht der Bundesregierung über die Lage der Medien 1994, Drucksache 12/8587 · German Bundestag · 1994-10-20

    Dutch Pearce · Analog Archives – Dima Andreyuk and the Tape Dealer (1984–1994) · Decibel Magazine · 2020-08-31

    History of Phonograms 1951–2000 – 1992 DCC / MiniDisc · IFPI Greece · Later industry chronology

    Massacre Records – label identification · MusicBrainz · Database record, updated 2019

    Discogs · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht. Descriptions of official releases, 14 records.

    Disposable Underground, 1993

    No author credited · ATROCITY – Longing for Death (standalone undated online review) · Death Metal Underground / deathmetal.org · No date · Original publication date unverified

    Nathan Robinson · Atrocity – Taste of Sin (retrospective reference in a review of a different release) · Metal-Rules.com · 2000-12-01

    arrrrrrrach: Longing for some fuckin amazing death metal!! (31 July 2004) · Encyclopaedia Metallum

    Wizard · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht · Sputnikmusic · 2011-09-24

    agymosott09 · Atrocity – Todessehnsucht (AOTD reader review, forum post) · Index Fórum – Metal Hammer H · #227257 · 2026-08-26

    Eckart Maronde · Atrocity – Interview mit Alexander Krull zu “Die Gottlosen Jahre” · metal.de · 2012-05-02

    Atrocity – Nuclear Blast: early label background on the band · Nuclear Blast – official label artist profile · Original publication date unknown

    Author unverified on original page · Atrocity – workoholics on tour (Alex Krull) · Schwermetall.ch · around 2007–2008; original day unknown

    DJ In Extremis · Atrocity (VO) – interview with Alex Krull and Thorsten “Tosso” Bauer · Spirit of Metal / DJ In Extremis · 2004-05

    Atrocity website editorial team – individual unverified · ATROCITY – 25 years “TODESSEHNSUCHT” album & history report · Atrocity official website · around early 2018; precise date unknown

    Concert Archives: Blind Guardian and Iced Earth, Rockfabrik, Ludwigsburg, 20 September 1992 (retrospective concert database). Contemporary text printed from EB/Metronom issue 39, p. 42, supports the date and venue; the overlapping columns leave the attribution of the performers uncertain.

    POP.FORUM club.award – 20 Jahre Musikkultur in Stuttgart: Konzerte 1987–2004; LKA Longhorn’s own retrospective concert list from 2006, p. 117. 21 September 1992: Testament; 22 September: GWAR. The 2006 list is not a concert poster issued in 1992.

    Cannibal Corpse: Tomb of the Mutilated. Metal Blade Records, US edition; 22 September 1992. MusicBrainz – retrospective release record. An original, day-specific label announcement from 1992 was not directly verified.

    Encyclopaedia Metallum – Cannibal Corpse, Tomb of the Mutilated. Supplementary retrospective album entry; does not establish a direct connection with Atrocity.

    Wetter Ludwigsburg: historical daily observations for Stuttgart-Schnarrenberg derived from DWD (station code 04928), September 1992. 22 Sept.: minimum 12.9 °C, maximum 27.7 °C, rainfall 3.4 mm, sunshine 9.3 hours; 23 Sept.: minimum 13.7 °C, maximum 18.3 °C, rainfall 1.6 mm, sunshine 0.9 hours. Daily summaries, not observations of the album’s retail-release hour or the weather at Fautspach. The original DWD daily dataset for station 04928 can be identified, but comparison with the two raw daily records remains outstanding.

    Official band channels and profiles

    Official websiteInstagramMetal Archives

    Related albums

    Death — Individual Thought Patterns (1993)Massacra — Signs of the Decline (1992)Disincarnate — Dreams of the Carrion Kind (1993)
    Share this article
    FacebookXWhatsAppTelegramRedditEmail
    OPEN METAL ALBUM LIBRARY · Newsletter

    Never miss a new album feature

    Get updates when new album features and music research are published.

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Subscription opens on the external Brevo website. Your email address is entered there, not on this website. Privacy notice.

    Back to the archive · Open Metal Album Library

    Search in this book

    Sources and references

    Open complete note